Fracking has No Effect on Groundwater: Study

Tuesday, March 8, 2016 @ 04:03 PM gHale


A three-year study by the University of Cincinnati found hydraulic fracturing of oil and gas wells like the Rex Energy well shown above, does not contaminate ground water.
Hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, has no effect on groundwater in the Utica shale region, new research found.

“We haven’t seen anything to show that wells have been contaminated by fracking,” said Dr. Amy Townsend-Small, lead researcher for the University of Cincinnati Department of Geology, which released the results during a Feb. 4 meeting of the Carroll County Concerned Citizens in Carrollton, OH.

RELATED STORIES
Concerns over Fracking, Drinking Water
Safety Plan to Rescue in Fracking Rig Fire
Toxins Found in Fracking Fluids: Research
Fracking Methane Can Flow to Empty Wells

When asked at that meeting if the university planned to publicize the results, Townsend-Small said there were no plans to do so.

“I am really sad to say this, but some of our funders, the groups that had given us funding in the past, were a little disappointed in our results. They feel that fracking is scary and so they were hoping this data could to a reason to ban it,” she said.

Rep. Andy Thompson, R-Marrietta, whose district includes Carroll, Harrison and Belmont counties, is calling for the university to release its findings. Thompson noted the study received state funding in the form of an $85,714 grant from the Ohio Board or Regents and federal funding from the national Science Foundation for an isotope ratio mass spectrometer.

“It is unacceptable that taxpayers have funded this important groundwater study and the findings are being kept from the public,” said Thompson. “UC still has not produced a full report of their findings, nor has the university issued a press release of their results. Yet, during the course of the past few years, the university has released countless advisories on the multi-year Groundwater Research of Ohio study. I am calling on the University of Cincinnati Department of Geology to release their full findings surrounding this study immediately. The people of Ohio have funded and deserve to know that private water wells in shale counties have not been impacted.”

The study aimed to measure methane and its sources in groundwater before, during and after the onset of fracking. The study corresponded with an increase in active gas wells in Carroll County from three in late 2011 to 354 in 2015. Wells in three counties listed above as well as Stark and Columbiana underwent testing. Groundwater from 27 private water wells, ranging from 35 to 115 meters in depth three to four times a year over a two-year period from November 2012 to February 2015.

A regional field campaign also ended up conducted in May 2014 in which researchers sampled 95 groundwater wells within the five counties. One hundred fifteen samples ended up collected from drinking water wells and two from springs. Participation in the study was voluntary.

A thesis paper submitted by Elizabeth Claire Botner (who participated in the study) as part of the requirements for her master’s degree in science, noted a majority of the study took place in Carroll County primarily for two reasons: 1.) a lack of water quality data exists in the region due and 2.) Carroll County has the greatest number of hydraulic fracturing permits in Ohio.

At the onset of the study, 161 wells had permits in the county and by the time the study concluded in May 2015, over 400 wells had permits.

A three-year study by the University of Cincinnati found hydraulic fracturing of oil and gas wells like the Rex Energy well shown above, does not contaminate ground water.

A three-year study by the University of Cincinnati found hydraulic fracturing of oil and gas wells like the Rex Energy well shown above, does not contaminate ground water.


Botner’s paper noted, “dissolved methane was detected in all sampled wells, however, no relationship was found between the methane concentration and proximity to natural gas wells. The highest levels of dissolved methane were observed at sites in Carroll and Stark counties and were more than 5 km from active gas wells.”

Through testing, researchers determined in three of the four sites with elevated levels the source of methane was coalbed gas. The other site is consistent with anaerobic respiration of soil organic carbon.

Botner’s paper also noted, “a small subset of groundwater wells in the Utica Shale region consistently contained elevated methane levels, but stable isotope analysis indicated biological sources.”

“While past studies have found evidence for Marcellus Shale-derived natural gas contamination in Pennsylvania drinking water wells due to improper well construction and maintenance, shale gas development firms may be using safer well construction practices in the relatively newer drilling area of the Utica Shale to avoid leakage from the well casings,” she said.

Botner noted, as did Townsend-Small, that continual monitoring of groundwater quality, methane concentration and sources must occur to assess the longer-term impacts of hydraulic fracturing.