A lawsuit brought by Japanese individuals and business who hoped to sue General Electric (GE) over its role in building and maintaining the reactors that exploded in the 2011 disaster at the Fukushima nuclear power plant in Japan ended up dismissed again, this time by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit.

The Japanese plaintiffs sued the company in federal court in Massachusetts, and they contended this was the appropriate forum because Japanese laws that governed liability for the disaster precluded them from recovering damages from GE if they sued in Japan.

The district court, however, dismissed the case last April on the grounds of “forum non conveniens,” holding that Japan, not U.S. federal court, is the adequate forum for the plaintiffs to recover for their losses.

The plaintiffs appealed and argued in the First Circuit the district court incorrectly assessed the adequacy of their legal relief in Japan, but the appeals court disagreed, stating Friday they agreed with the lower court and, on a couple of points, they “have little difficulty concluding that the district court did not abuse its discretion.”

Schneider Bold

Compensation for the Fukushima disaster in Japan is covered by a 1961 law addressing nuclear damages — the Compensation Act. The Compensation Act creates a complex scheme with several ways for injured parties to recover, and it ultimately places all liability for Fukushima in the Tokyo Electric Power Company (TEPCO) that operated the plant.

The plaintiffs in the lawsuit against GE, as well as millions of others, had recovered money from TEPCO in Japan through lawsuits, claims directly to the company, and mediated processes. But the plaintiffs in this case also wanted to recover money from GE, which had built, designed or maintained all the reactors at Fukushima, and, according to the plaintiffs, were responsible for some of what went wrong there during the tsunami in 2011.

The plaintiffs sued in Massachusetts because GE is headquartered there.

GE argued, however, the case should be dismissed because an adequate forum exists in Japan and that practical considerations favor litigating there. GE noted it was available to be served process in Japan and subject to jurisdiction there. The Massachusetts District Court held that GE met its burden of showing it an inappropriate forum when it dismissed the case in April 2019.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This