That was just one fact in the annual research the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) conducts in its Risk and Vulnerability Assessments (RVA) of Federal Civilian Executive Branch (FCEB), Critical Infrastructure (CI), and State, Local, Tribal, and Territorial (SLTT) stakeholders.
Each RVA assesses the entity’s network capabilities and network defenses against potential threats. In Fiscal Year 21, CISA conducted 112 RVA assessments of multiple stakeholders across various sectors. The results of the RVAs end up mapped to the MITRE ATT&CK framework.
The goal of RVA is to develop effective strategies that help stakeholders.
Attack Path
As a part of the analysis, the report analyzes a sample attack path a cyber threat actor could take to compromise an organization, using weaknesses identified in the RVAs. The path comprises 11 successive tactics or steps: Initial access, execution, persistence, privilege escalation, defense evasion, credential access, discovery, lateral movement, collection, command and control, and exfiltration. In addition to this analysis, the report includes the following observations:
- Most successful attacks were achieved through methods commonly used by threat actors, such as phishing and the use of default credentials.
- The list of tools and techniques used to conduct common attacks are constantly changing.
- Many organizations exhibited the same weaknesses.
CISA developed a sample attack path, based loosely on the ATT&CK methods used by the assessment teams and the varying success rates of each tactic and technique. Although the sample attack path is not all-encompassing of the potential steps used by threat actors – and not all attack paths follow this model – a skilled threat actor could follow this path to successfully exploit its target. The sample attack path steps serve to highlight the more successful attack strategies used during RVAs and the impacts these strategies have had on target networks.
The attack path begins with a step required by many real-world attacks: gaining Initial Access. Next, the attacker Executes code in the network to help establish a foothold and retain Persistence on the network. Using the initial foothold within the network, the attacker will use Privilege Escalation to gain administrative rights. Then the attacker will use Defense Evasion to avoid detection, allowing the attacker to try and steal access with Credential Access. Once the attacker has credential access, they will Discover the systems and networks to gain an understanding of the infrastructure. After understanding the network, they will use Lateral Movement throughout the network and access sensitive data. Once entrenched in the network, the focus of the path switches to the Collection of sensitive data. Attackers use Command and Control to keep communication channels open to support data Exfiltration and potential control after the attack.
In a real world example, CISA chose the Advanced Persistent Threat (APT) Group 28 to highlight a real-world demonstration of how each step is enacted.
Open Valid Accounts
In one of the details, RVA analyses revealed valid accounts were the most common successful attack technique, responsible for 51 percent of successful attempts to gain initial access. Valid accounts can be previous employee accounts that have not been removed from the active directory or default administrator accounts.
The CISA Assessment team conducted 112 RVAs intended to assess the participating entities’ network capabilities and network defenses against potential threats. After conducting trend analysis on entities’ networks and network defenses, CISA had several observations from enhanced security to patching outdated software.
During the initial access phase, many organizations fell victim to common access methods, such as phishing and the use of default credentials. This demonstrates initial attack vectors have not changed over time and organizations should continue to implement enhanced password protection practices. Since attack vectors have not changed and remain successful, all sectors should focus on enhancing password requirements, implementing user training to identify phishing, and requiring password changes after a set period.
Network defenders should remain vigilant to threat actors’ evolving tactics and techniques. To help quickly identify abnormal activity, network defenders should continuously review intrusion detection systems and logs to identify adversary activity. During its RVAs, CISA was able to escalate privilege and laterally move throughout entities’ networks, gaining access to sensitive information. If entities can quickly identify malicious activity, they can reduce the impact of compromise.
Common Weaknesses
CISA observed organizations across multiple sectors exhibited similar weaknesses, such as a prevalence of default passwords, open ports, and outdated software. CISA recommends all industries practice strong password management to reduce the risk of compromise, patch outdated software, and close inactive ports.
In addition to the recommendations and mitigations provided after each section, CISA recommends individual organizations create additional tailored guidance to fit their specific network architectures, while dealing with their specific resource constraints.
CISA encourages system owners and administrators to convey its guidance to their leadership and apply changes relevant to the nuances of their specific environments. CISA concluded analysis of this nature may effectively prioritize the identification and mitigation of high-level vulnerabilities across multiple sectors and agencies.
Click here for more details on the CISA Analysis: FY2021 Risk and Vulnerability Assessments.
Click here to view an infographic on the CISA analysis.

