By Gregory Hale
It wasn’t that long ago when attacks on industrial control systems (ICS) were not that different than attacks on any other system in any industry. That is because attackers knew how to create an attack methodology, and that is all they needed.

OT security experts always feared, though, what if attackers had a knowledge of ICS systems and knew where to go and what to hit and take over for the maximum benefit of the attack. Those days OT experts fretted over are here and now is the time for the industry to really step of their game to protect against any kind of attack headed their way.

That is because attackers traversing critical infrastructure networks have knowledge of control system components, industrial protocols, and engineering operations, according to results of the 2022 SANS ICS/OT Cybersecurity survey.

“While threat actors are honing their ICS skills, the specialized technologies and frameworks for a solid defense are available,” said Nozomi Networks co-founder and chief product officer Andrea Carcano. “The survey found that more organizations are proactively using them. Still, there’s work to be done. We encourage others to take steps now to minimize risk and maximize resilience.”

Schneider Bold

The 2022 SANS ICS/OT survey received 332 responses representing a wide range of industrial verticals from the energy, chemical, critical manufacturing, nuclear, water management, and other industries.

ICS Targeted
From attacks such as CRASHOVERRIDE in the electric sector, human machine interface hijacking through remote access in water management in Oldsmar, Florida, and ICS-specific ransomware in the manufacturing and energy sectors, to the Incontroller/PIPEDREAM advanced scalable attack framework targeting multiple ICS sectors, ICS/OT attacks are more disruptive with the possibility of physically destructive capabilities, the survey found. Threat intelligence supports the fact industrial security defenders across all sectors must address new challenges and face serious threats.

Insights from this survey include:

  • Significant change in who is being called to perform ICS incident response
  • A shift in the responsibility for implementing security controls in ICS/OT
  • Continued value and investment in ICS-specific training and skillset development
  • Steady increase in obtaining the benefits of an ICS asset inventory
  • A more dedicated focus on ICS operations
  • A significant uptake in ICS-specific threat intelligence for active threat-hunt defense
  • Industry struggles on actions related to threat detection coverage
  • Continued adoption of MITRE ATT&CK for ICS framework

In the survey, 22 percent of respondents consider the current cybersecurity threats toward ICS as severe/critical, whereas 41 percent consider them to be high. This represents a slight but steady increase year over year across 2019 (38 percent), 2021 (40 percent), and 2022 (41 percent).

Facilities recognize the business is the control systems running critical engineering assets, and they must be protected for business survival. With the evolution of new attack frameworks, legacy devices, evolving technology options, and resource constraints, the biggest challenge with securing control systems technologies and processes is the technical integration of legacy and aging ICS/OT technology with modern IT systems. Facilities are confronted with the fact that traditional IT security technologies are not designed for control systems and cause disruption in ICS/OT environments, and they need direction on prioritizing ICS- specific controls to protect their priority assets.

ICS Challenges
Respondents said the biggest challenges faced in securing ICS/OT technologies and processes, are as follows:

  • Legacy and aging OT technology must be technically integrated with modern IT systems
  • Traditional IT security technologies are not designed for control systems and cause disruption in OT environments
  • IT staff does not understand OT operational requirements
  • There are insufficient labor resources to implement existing security plans

When asked which control system components were considered at greatest risk for compromise, respondents said the engineering workstation or instrumentation laptop, which scored the same as last year, at nearly 54 percent. This year, however, operator assets such as a human machine interface (HMI) or operator workstation took over the second spot at 43 percent a jump from 32 percent the prior year. Servers running commercial operating systems dropped to the third spot from being second last year.

In terms of using operator assets, ICS attack groups have been abusing systems, features, and industry protocols native to industrial environments, turning control systems against themselves. Some examples of living off the land are an attacker gaining access to an HMI with legitimate operator access but then using the HMI commands against the process to, for example, open circuit breakers in the field in an electric substation or change the chemical mixture in a water treatment facility. No malware is used to cause the impact; rather, the adversaries are using built-in and legitimate engineering software, features, and/or ICS protocols to cause impacts.

Responsibility for implementing ICS security controls has shifted.

A majority of organizations said the responsibility belongs to the owner or operator of the ICS (38 percent) or the engineering manager (36 percent).

That is a difference from last year when the responsibility was most often assigned to the IT manager role, which fell to third in 2022. This shift in responsible parties appears to align with those working day to day more directly focused on engineering operations and safety, according to the report.

Invest in Security
While security is all about people, process and technology, dedicated resources for people and tools will drive the ICS security program to meet the challenges. Only asset owners who continue to invest in control system security can hope to mature, detect, protect, and defend it. To that end, more organizations are obtaining an increased ICS security budget.

Most organizations now have budgets allocated between $100,000 and $499,999 (27 percent) or between $500,000 and $999,999 (25 percent).

Looking to the next 18 months, respondents are allocating those budgets toward several initiatives; planning for increased visibility into cyber assets and their configurations (42 percent) and the implementation of network-based anomaly and intrusion detection tools (34 percent) showed the highest focus. Closely behind there’s a focus on network-based intrusion prevention tools on control-system networks (26 percent) followed by increased consulting services.

“The number one item on the list of initiatives to act on in the next 18 months for over 41 percent of those surveyed, was to improve asset visibility,” said Peter Lund, vice president of Products – OT Security at OPSWAT. “Having a solution in place that gives its operator a clear picture of what’s connected on your network, key information about the connected asset (country of origin, firmware, make and model, etc.), and threat level goes a long way in mitigating the risk of intrusion, but it is only the first step; don’t stop there.”

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This