Sounds and vibrations constantly surround everyone these days; just look at, or listen to, a ringing phone or a buzzing smart device like a wearable activity tracker.
While such notifications from personal devices can be an efficient way of alerting users to an incoming call or email, they can also distract users from what they are currently doing. That is exactly what a team of researchers from Yale-NUS College sought to learn.
The team, led by Yale-NUS Assistant Professor of Social Sciences (Psychology) Christopher Asplund and Singapore University of Technology and Design’s Assistant Professor Simon Perrault, found haptic feedback (such as a vibration) does cause distraction, but this loss of focus lasts only for about one second. The findings can help designers improve the usability of notification features in devices.
Information conveyed through haptic feedback has advantages as it can alert users privately (as compared to a ringing phone) and during physical activities. Moreover, there has been increased interest in further developing haptic interfaces in devices in recent years. While distraction from visual and auditory feedback has been extensively studied, Asplund said the distraction caused by haptic feedback remains poorly understood.
This latest study provides new information on the attentional capture effects in haptic feedback and offers suggestions for designing alerts in smart devices.
“Distracting sounds and vibrations in the environment capture users’ attention, and we wanted to understand its impact on doing other things,” Asplund said. “So if you are surprised by an unexpected vibration from your activity monitor, will you fail to notice your buzzing phone? The answer appears to be yes, but the timing matters: The distraction effects are strong but last for only about a second. That’s why we think that devices could be designed to compensate for our distractibility, either by separating the sending of critical information in time or by detecting distracting events and then delaying the presentation of information to the user.”
Along those lines, the team recommended smart devices should have dynamically scheduled notifications where multiple alerts end up separated by at least one second.
In addition, devices can end up designed to actively sense unexpected vibrations or sounds in the environment and consequently delay notifications until the optimal time gap is reached to minimize distractions to the user. For example, a smart watch could delay non-urgent notifications such as emails when the user is running.

