By Gregory Hale
Safety is paramount and a given in the chemical industry, there is no doubt about it, but what was refreshing to see, and witness, was the discussion going on about the importance of cybersecurity throughout the sector.
It wasn’t long ago where industry wags discussed the importance of safety – and rightly so – but security was just an afterthought. Those days, however, now appear to be gone and the sun is shining on coupling safety and security together. It only makes sense.
“We all come from a background of if it ain’t broke don’t fix it, but with cybersecurity, it just doesn’t work that way,” said Marco Ayala, lifecycle services manager – Process Safety, Automation and Cyber Security at aeSolutions during multiple sessions at 2020 AIChE Spring Meeting & 16th Global Congress on Process Safety last month devoted to understanding cybersecurity. “It comes down to the approach. Cybersecurity really intersects in the safety paradigm. It is imperative to tie both safety and cybersecurity awareness practices into your program.”
Protecting the House
“We typically lock the doors at the house, how secure do you feel about that? Robertson asked. “Would you feel more secure if you had an alarm? That is what detection is all about, having an alarm to let you know someone has gotten in.
A typical business network, Robertson said, is broken into different layers:
1. Internet or cloud, the outside world.
2. Typically, a firewall between that and your business network.
3. Commonly security systems deploy a DMZ that has firewalls on both sides, so it can restrict traffic; only pulling certain parts of the process control data up to corporate through the DMZ. It has another firewall between it and the process control zone that limits access between the DMZ and the actual devices doing process control. It is a place to store things and provide access to the business. This is a place they can both talk to and if an attack comes it actually doesn’t break any process control stuff.
4. Process control network.
The catch is, though, hackers can get past these firewalls by creating a phishing attack to trick someone to click on a malware-laden attachment that will allow a bad guy into the system bypassing all the security.
Once they are in, if they know about process control, they will spend time learning about the system and they can use the tools to reprogram, Robertson said. They can program details to where it is looking like nothing is happening and everything is fine, but in reality, havoc is breaking loose.
Safeguards
What safeguards do you have to protect against phishing? Typically, today they have intrusion detection systems (IDS) that can identify the traffic where you can block the traffic or you can quarantine the traffic, Robertson said.
“It can see stuff where if someone got around the security technology, the IDS can see it and root out unusual behavior,” he said.
There are issues with IDS’, though. It can only see what it is in physical position to intercept, Robertson said. Once malware is installed on an engineering workstation on the secure layer it has already passed the IDS and it won’t see the traffic between it and the other devices on the control network, so it can’t respond to it.
One solution, Robertson said, is to put appliances at lower levels, put it right on the device you are trying to protect. It can get expensive, but it can protect against anomalous communication between workstations. It can detect these things at a much lower level.
Another way to secure the network is to create segmentation.
Segmentation
By putting a security appliance between different pieces of the network and breaking it up into smaller pieces, or segments, an attacker would have to defeat all the different segments and give the user a better chance to detect exploits and ward off an attack.
Robertson provided an analogy relating cybersecurity to protecting a home.
“A firewall is like a good solid front door; a centralized intrusion detection is like a great alarm on the front door or a camera looking down the hallway: a distributed intrusion detection system is motion sensors, glass breaks, cameras, detectors throughout the house, and segmentation is where we are actually blocking the traffic, I am locking every door in the house, you will have to break every lock in every room, slowing you down.”
Robertson alluded to the fact if an attacker wants to get in, there is no stopping him or her, so segmentation is one way to slow down the attack. Mark Baggett, vice president of industrial control systems at Mission Secure, Inc. discussed how to maintain operability during a cyber attack, how do you safely bring down processes when compromised, and how do you recover and restore cyber-physical systems after the attack?
“We are trying to get the protection down as low as possible in the network so the operator can trust everything he is seeing,” Baggett said.
Hackers are getting in via multiple different ways these days. From connected printers to corrupted supply chains to watering hole attacks from sites where users can download manuals, malware attacks continue to hit the sector.
Baggett said an attacker uses a three-pronged approach after getting into a system.
“They first attack the safety system,” he said. “They first take out the permissives to allow a shut down, then they attack the HMI. They spoof the HMI where the operator is looking at the screen and give him a bogus signal where he would not respond to it because everything looks normal. The next thing to do is to attack the PLC or the DCS.”
Offset the Attack
There is a way to offset that kind of attack that gives a redundant feeling of security, Baggett said. You have to go below the control system. You take the signals from a field device and bring it to another system and that system verifies what the operator is looking at. It is not cost effective to do it with all the points in a plant. But learn your critical points, the ones that tells you your plant is running right.
“We worked with a refinery and they had about eight or 10 points; they knew if those points were running correctly, the system was running correctly. We suggested they take those eight or 10 points and bring them to a secondary system, and they were able to verify what the operator was seeing. They are seeing the data before it can be hacked into, before it gets into the system. If you see something that is not correct, you immediately notify the operator and let them know you cannot trust that signal. If the operator sees that signal you need to take a manual verification. He can take manual control of the system. We are trying to make sure safety is first and the plant is running in control.”
Understanding how important cybersecurity truly is within the company’s ecosystem is not just a singular one person or one team approach, rather it is everybody’s business to ensure a safe and secure operation.

