The Chemical Safety Board (CSB) asked a judge to order Harris County to hand over documents related to two chemical fires, saying the delay in responding is hindering two of its investigations.

Federal prosecutors in Houston filed a petition Wednesday to order Harris County Fire Marshal Laurie L. Christensen to produce documents and other relevant materials related to the investigations, according to a published report. The CSB said the county has failed to comply with requests even after it issued administrative subpoenas.

“The CSB’s attempts to conduct an efficient and effective set of investigations have been harmed by hostility and entrenchment of the county’s asserted legal positions,” Dan Tillema, investigator-in-charge, wrote in a court affidavit, according to the report.

The fire marshal’s office said it had requested an opinion from the Texas attorney general regarding the release of specific information requested by the CSB, and it “stated that certain information could not be released because it is a part of an ongoing criminal investigation,” said Rachel Moreno, a spokeswoman for the office in the published report.

Schneider Bold

Moreno added the fire marshal’s office “provides information to all local, state and federal entities interested, as permissible by law.”

Moreno said the office responded to the board’s subpoena. Among other things, the Harris County Attorney’s Office had said providing the information to the CSB would interfere with its own investigation and prosecution of a crime and the materials being sought were protected by attorney-client privilege, according to court documents.

The CSB is an independent federal agency charged with investigating industrial chemical accidents.

Board officials said six of its seven investigators were sent to Harris County after the March 17 fire and explosion at the Intercontinental Terminals Co. (ITC) complex in Deer Park, which engulfed 11 chemical storage tanks and sent a plume of hazardous smoke into the air that was visible for miles. It also led to the temporary closure of the Houston Ship Channel and to multiple orders for community members to shelter in place.

Then, two weeks later, KMCO, a chemical manufacturing facility in Crosby, caught fire, killing one worker and injuring at least 30 others. The board’s investigators are also looking into this incident.

The board said team members were to conduct parallel investigations of the incidents, but when they arrived at the scene, they were met with hostility from officials with the fire marshal’s office.

Tillema, a chemical incident investigator, wrote in a sworn statement that on March 27, one of the CSB’s investigators attended a meeting at which county officials asked all interviews and site investigations be coordinated with the fire marshal’s office.

This made investigators “feel extremely uncomfortable with the idea of needless delays,” he said, but they understood it would help the relationship with the county.

Tillema said county officials also told the CSB investigators they couldn’t request comments directly from the companies, but instead had to go through Harris County.

CSB investigators said both companies, ITC and KMCO, had been fully cooperative until they were told by officials with the fire marshal’s office to stop doing so, according to the court petition filed in the Southern District of Texas.

The county had shared information with the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration, he said, but explicitly told them not to share it with the CSB because it was not an enforcement agency.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This