The cybersecurity refrain when encountering phishing emails invariably advises: “don’t click on that link” and “report that email.”

In the end, though, most major companies do little to support reporting and few take action to shut down phishing sites disguised as their own after they have been reported, according to research from Drexel University and Arizona State University.

To that end, an extensive investigation into reporting resources and processes – including an empirical test of their efficacy – revealed less than half of Fortune 100 companies offer any channel for reporting these scams.

And an experiment, to test the companies’ response to reports of phishing attacks impersonating their websites, found nearly 30 percent of reported websites never ended up accessed as part of an investigation and only 3 percent of them ever ended up blocked from access.

Smishing Attacks
Most phishing emails include links to download malware or visit fake webpages that mimic popular sites. Recipients end up tricked into attempting to log in to the sites, divulging their account information to the bad actors behind them. Variations on this cyberattack, called smishing, which involves sending malicious links in text messages; and vishing, which uses voicemails, are also becoming more prevalent.

Schneider Bold

Despite ever-evolving cybersecurity techniques to detect and block the malicious scams, quite a few still make it through countermeasures and into inboxes. In 2022, the FBI received more reports of phishing than any other type of cybercrime – an 11-fold increase since 2018.

Because of this evasiveness, most companies provide cybersecurity training to help employees identify and instruct them to report phishing emails as a last line of defense.

When phishing emails end up reported, the companies impersonated can take steps to mitigate the scam, including updating their security systems, re-securing compromised email accounts and reporting the fraud to federal authorities and report any website listed in the email so the company can take it down, or “block listed.”

But research suggests the rate of phishing attack reporting is strikingly low.

A 2020 study by researchers at Arizona State showed phishing sites end up visited an average of 27 times before it ended up reported.

In hopes of improving participation in anti-phishing measures, cybersecurity researchers from Drexel University’s College of Computing & Informatics sought to better understand the reporting ecosystem that generates such a low rate of participation. Their report, which is one of the first comprehensive studies to look at the attitudes and actions around phishing reporting, uncovered the challenges and concerns people face when reporting, as well as shortcomings in how the reports end up handled.

How to Report Phishing
“Although users are constantly trained and instructed on how to identify and report phishing emails, the reaction they receive in the actions taken – or, more often, not taken – by the companies to which they report creates a negative feedback that discourages them from reporting future emails,” said Eric Sun, PhD, an assistant professor in Drexel’s College of Computing & Informatics who helped to lead the research. “Our research sheds a light on what it’s like to be a reporter and a company that receives a phishing report in hopes of improving this cybersecurity environment.”

The team approached its analysis from three perspectives, seeking to understand:

  • The options the cybersecurity ecosystem provides to individuals who wish to report phishing attacks
  • The actual experience in preparing to report a phishing attack
  • The post-reporting response – what happens to phishing websites after reporting and what feedback ends up  conveyed to reporters

It found that although there is a great deal of room for improvement in the guidance information and feedback provided by companies and enforcement institutions, individual reporting of phishing attacks remains a crucial part of cybersecurity efforts.

After conducting an extensive search and filtering out official guidance offered by .gov, .org sites and the websites of the top 100 brand-name U.S. companies (Fortune 100), the team identified 575 webpages providing guidance about phishing attacks.

An analysis of those resources showed there are five main channels for reporting phishing: Email, built in reporting button in email software, SMS text, online reporting forms, and direct contact through a phone call or live chat.

Government Agencies
The team identified eight government agencies and two anti-phishing organizations providing information and guidance about phishing: Federal Trade Commission (FTC), Internal Revenue Service (IRS), Cybersecurity & Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3), Department of Homeland Security (DHS), Department of Justice (DOJ), Federal Communications Commission (FCC), Government Information and Services, Anti-Phishing Working Group (APWG), and Phishing.org.

While all offered security advice on reporting phishing, only half of them actually provided dedicated channels for reporting phishing.

A summary of the advice offered by these agencies and organizations show they primarily direct victims to one or several of 12 options: FTC, IRS, CISA, FCC, IC3, police, state attorney general’s office, APWG, the national SMS reporting number (7726), Google, the impersonated company, their internet service provider.

“Understandably, many organizations play a role in mitigating, investigating and enforcing laws against cybercrime, this can also raise confusion when it comes to reporting crimes like phishing,” said Gail-Joon Ahn, PhD, a professor at Arizona State University who helped to lead the research. “We found that due to this enforcement environment, a great deal of the reporting advice offered online is inconsistent or conflicting.”

The team’s analysis of reporting resources provided by Fortune 100 companies revealed only 65 of them provide guidance to their customers on how to report a phishing attack. Only 44 of them provided channels for directly reporting a phishing attack impersonating – or “spoofing” – the company’s website, despite the prevalence of security advice recommending reporting such deceptions to those companies.

No Real Reporting Channels
“We’re constantly advised to avoid clicking on phishing links and to report them, especially to the spoofed companies,” Sun said. “Our finding that only 65 of the Fortune 100 companies provide advice for reporting phishing attacks – and less than half of them offer actual reporting channels – is particularly striking given these companies have more resources and are expected to be more committed to handling such reports.”

Through this analysis the group found four challenges common to both government/organizations and the Fortune 100 companies that may be discouraging people from reporting phishing attacks:

  • Reporting procedures for email phishing attacks typically do not require critical information, such as email headers (including sender and recipient details, timestamps, or IP addresses).
  • Different reporting channels offer different and sometimes conflicting or outdated advice. For example, some companies instruct victims to report the phishing, others just advise them to delete it without reporting.
  • Security advice requests people report the same phishing to too many places (i.e. FTC, IC3, and APWG).
  • Reporters generally do not receive feedback other than an auto-reply email confirming receipt of the report.

In addition to understanding the existing reporting resources and guidance, the team tried to better understand the experience and sentiments of people who report phishing attacks.

To do it they recruited 89 U.S.-based participants to individually go through the process of locating reporting information and filing a report of a phishing attack. Surveying the participants after this short process provided a snapshot of peoples’ experience, attitudes and concerns about reporting.

Of the 89 participants, 15 decided not to report the phishing email. Most suggested it wasn’t worth the time they’d spend on it, or that nothing would be done with the report. Others noted that they would only file a report if it reached a certain threshold – receiving the same phishing email multiple times, for example.

In the final step of their investigation the team looked at how companies and organizations responsible for dealing with phishing sites respond to reports. What they found indicates concerns expressed by reporters about lack of response and communication are not unfounded.

Click here for more on the report.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This