A failed Aghorn Operating, Inc. water flood station in Odessa, Texas, pump revealed the component that most likely led to the release of a deadly gas was a piece of equipment referred to as a “plunger,” and in addition, a hydrogen sulfide alarm system may not have been performing as expected, federal investigators found.

Those are just some of the findings released by the Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) in a factual update detailing the events surrounding the double fatal incident October 26, 2019, hydrogen sulfide release at the water flood station. Hydrogen sulfide is a colorless, flammable, and toxic gas that is present in the area’s oil and gas reservoirs. The release resulted in two fatalities – an Aghorn employee, Jacob Dean, and his wife, Natalee Dean.

So far the CSB investigative team determined the following details related to the fatal incident:

  • During the evening of October 26, 2019, a component of a pump inside the waterflood station failed, resulting in the release of water containing hydrogen sulfide.
  • Likely after the pump component failure, at 6:38 p.m., a control board within the station registered an oil level alarm for the failed pump.
  • Five minutes later, at 6:43 p.m., the alarm system triggered an automatic phone notification to an Aghorn employee. As part of the normal job duties, the employee drove to the facility to determine the cause of the alarm. While the employee was in the pump house, the employee was overcome by hydrogen sulfide gas.
  • Around 9:30 p.m., having not heard back from her husband for a few hours, the employee’s wife and their two children drove to the waterflood station in her personal vehicle to check on him. After arriving at the facility, it appears she entered the pump house to look for her husband and was also overcome by hydrogen sulfide gas.
  • Just after 10:00 p.m. first responders arrived at the scene and were able to rescue the two children who were still in the wife’s vehicle. Later that night both the employee and his wife were found deceased inside the pump house.
  • The following day, October 27, 2019, emergency responders shut a valve that isolated the pump from the water tanks stopping the leak.

“They were both found deceased at that location. She had two children in the car with her,” said Sheriff Mike Griffis at the time of the incident. “They were exposed to some gas, but they were taken to the Medical Center Hospital and they appear to be fine.”

As a result of its investigation so far, CSB said it completed the following activities:
1. Examination of the failed pump revealed the component of the pump that most likely led to the release was a piece of equipment referred to as a “plunger.”
2. The site was equipped with a hydrogen sulfide alarm system – following the incident testing of the system suggested the alarm system may not have been performing as expected.

Schneider Bold

H2S is a byproduct of crude oil and natural gas, Griffis said. It is a very deadly substance, and just one breath could take a life.

“It’s very prevalent in this area,” said Griffis. “There’s not a whole lot of incidents involving that due to all the training that has gone on throughout the years. I’m not aware if there was a sensor on that location or not.”

Pump house that emitted deadly H2S gas that left a husband and wife dead.


The CSB’s investigation is still ongoing – currently the board plans to release its final report this year.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This