The report from a bipartisan Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee found seven federal agencies “have not met the basic cybersecurity standards necessary to protect America’s sensitive data.” According to data from each agency’s inspector general, the average grade for information security maturity among large federal agencies was a C-.
Two years ago, the bipartisan report released saying there were systemic failures of eight key federal agencies.
The 2019 report documented how none of these eight agencies met basic cybersecurity standards and protocols, including properly protecting Americans’ personally identifiable information (PII); maintaining a list of the equipment and programs on agency networks; and promptly installing security patches to remediate vulnerabilities that hackers could exploit.
Two years later, a new report released and the results were disappointing to say the least.
The report identified many of the same issues that plagued federal agencies for more than a decade. Seven agencies made minimal improvements, and only DHS managed to employ an effective cybersecurity regime for 2020. The most recent report found seven federal agencies still have not met the basic cybersecurity standards necessary to protect America’s sensitive data.
This report releases on the heels of the Biden administration saying U.S. critical infrastructure companies, such as energy providers, must improve their cyber defenses because additional government regulation is on the horizon.
Biden signed a national security memorandum last week, launching a new public-private initiative that creates “performance controls” for cybersecurity at America’s most critical companies, including water treatment and electrical power plants.
The recommendations are voluntary in nature, but the administration hopes it will cause companies to improve their cybersecurity ahead of other policy efforts, said a senior administration official.
That announcement comes after multiple high profile cyberattacks this year crippled American companies and government agencies, including the Colonial Pipeline ransomware incident which disrupted gasoline supplies on the East Coast.
In this Senate report, the agencies mentioned are the departments of State, Health and Human Services, Transportation, Education, Agriculture, and Housing and Urban Development, as well as the Social Security Administration (SSA). Of these organizations, the departments of Education and Transportation along with the SSA in particular “showed very little improvement” since 2019.
NASA and the Office of Personnel Management, meanwhile, were given Ds for their cybersecurity posture.
- The following are recommendations the panel suggested:
- OMB should develop and require agencies to adopt a risk-based budgeting model for information technology investments.
- There should be a centrally coordinated approach for Government-wide cybersecurity to ensure accountability.
- CISA’s Cybersecurity Quality Services Management Office should expand shared services offerings to Federal agencies, including improved, Government-wide endpoint detection using primarily commercial off the shelf products and services to improve the operational effectiveness of EINSTEIN, DHS’s flagship cybersecurity program for federal agencies – the National Cybersecurity Protection System (NCPS).
- The Department of Homeland Security should provide Congress with a plan to update EINSTEIN and to justify its cost.
- The annual Inspector General FISMA Reporting Metrics developed by OMB, DHS, and the Council of the Inspectors General on Integrity and
- Efficiency should prioritize risk-based metrics that best demonstrate the maturity of an agency’s information security program.
- Congress should update the Federal Information Security Modernization Act of 2014 to reflect current cybersecurity best practices, to formalize CISA’s role as the operational lead for Federal cybersecurity, require Federal agencies and contractors notify CISA of certain cyber, and define “major incident” in a way that ensures Federal agencies notify Congress in a timely manner of significant cyber incidents instead of continuing to rely on the current definition which has promoted inconsistent notification to Congress.
Click here for more on the report.

