The goal of the Control System Defense: Know the Opponent is to provide critical infrastructure owners and operators with an understanding of the tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs) used by malicious cyber actors.
This advisory builds on NSA and CISA 2021 guidance provided to stop malicious ICS activity against connect OT, and 2020 guidance to reduce OT exposure.
A malicious actors’ game plan for control system intrusions includes these steps, according to the advisory:
- Establish intended effect and select a target
- Collect intelligence about the target system
- Develop techniques and tools to navigate and manipulate the system
- Gain initial access to the system
- Execute techniques and tools to create the intended effect
Leveraging specific expertise and network knowledge, malicious actors such as nation-state actors can conduct these steps in a coordinated manner, sometimes concurrently and repeatedly, as illustrated by real world cyber activity.
The complexity of balancing network security with performance, features, ease-of-use, and availability can be overwhelming for owner/operators. This is especially true where system tools and scripts enable ease-of-use and increase availability or functionality of the control network; and when equipment vendors require remote access for warranty compliance, service obligations, and financial/billing functionality. However, with the increase in targeting of OT/ICS by malicious actors, owner/operators should be more cognizant of the risks when making these balancing decisions.
System owners and operators cannot prevent a malicious actor from targeting their systems. Understanding that being targeted is not an “if” but a “when” is essential context for making ICS security decisions. By assuming the system is being targeted and predicting the effects that a malicious actor would intend to cause, owner/operators can employ and prioritize mitigation actions.
Owner/operators can apply a few straightforward ICS security best practices to counter attacks:
Limit exposure of system information: Operational and system information and configuration data is a key element of critical infrastructure operations. The importance of keeping such data confidential cannot be overstated.
Identify and secure remote access points: Owner/operators must maintain detailed knowledge of all installed systems, including which remote access points are – or could be – operating in the control system network. Creating a full “connectivity inventory” is a critical step in securing access to the system.
Restrict tools and scripts: Limit access to network and control system application tools and scripts to legitimate users performing legitimate tasks on the control system. Removing the tools and scripts entirely and patching embedded control system components for exploitable vulnerabilities is often not feasible.
Conduct regular security audits: The owner/operator of the control system should consider performing an independent security audit of the system, especially of third-party vendor access points and systems.
Implement a dynamic network environment: Static network environments provide malicious actors with persistent knowledge of the system. A static network can provide cyber actors the opportunity to collect bits of intelligence about the system over time, establish long-term accesses into the system, and develop the tools and TTPs to affect the control system as intended.
Click here for more on the Control System Defense: Know the Opponent.

