By Chris Powell
Imagine discovering a critical flaw in your safety system design before your plant goes operational. This scenario, while nerve-wracking, underscores the importance of early intervention in the design phase.
When developing a Safety Instrumented System (SIS), it’s crucial to ensure the hardware and software meet the practical needs identified from the initial hazard and risk assessment. That’s the purpose of a functional safety assessment (FSA).
FSAs, as defined by IEC 61511, provide a five-stage, evidence-based investigation to judge the functional safety achieved by one or more SIS and/or other protection layers.
Can Reduce Incidents
A well-executed FSA reduces the likelihood of safety incidents. Here’s what to expect in the Stage 1 FSA process, along with recommendations for a successful outcome:
For FSA Stage 1, the primary goal is to verify the safety requirements specification (SRS) accurately reflects the needs identified during the hazard and risk assessments. Does what’s on paper reflect the scenario in which the SIS must operate in the real world? Will the SIS accurately mitigate the risks identified in the hazard and risk assessment?
By ensuring thorough verification of the SRS at this early stage, Stage 1 FSAs help prevent costly modifications and delays later in the project lifecycle. Proper planning leads to smoother project execution, reducing downtime and increasing overall efficiency.
The deliverable for a Stage 1 FSA includes a comprehensive report that presents findings, recommendations, and general observations. It is a good idea to loop in stakeholders to review this deliverable together to align on opportunities to course-correct and next steps. Key personnel include process engineers, control engineers, operations supervisors, and leadership.
The effort for executing an FSA is minimal relative to the overall project.
The initial cost of performing a Stage 1 FSA includes expenses related to document reviews, stakeholder interviews, and detailed analyses. The expense is minimal compared to the total project cost. The duration of a Stage 1 FSA can vary based on the project’s size and complexity, typically involving several days of document reviews and interviews with key personnel.

Costly Fixes
Failing to conduct a thorough Stage 1 FSA can lead to incomplete or incorrect safety requirements. This oversight can result in costly modifications, delays, and potentially catastrophic failures once the system is operational. These issues often incur far higher costs than the initial FSA investment. A Stage 1 FSA can help surface the following issues:
- Incomplete risk assessments
- Failure to capture safety requirements
- Insufficient detail in the preliminary assessments
- Inadequate stakeholder engagement
Conducting a Stage 1 FSA allows for early identification of design flaws and safety issues, which are less expensive to address in the design phase than during or after construction.
The FSA Stage 1 process typically consists of the following steps:
- Hazard and risk assessment verification
- Verification of safety requirements specification
- Operational readiness
As renewable energy sources reach maturity in the market, the nature of hazards and associated risks change with new unknowns and limited data.
Consider the unique explosion and flammability risks of hydrogen, which is relatively new to the market. The hazard and risk assessments for hydrogen facilities must account for these unique dangers.
Unknown Renewable Energy Risks
Similarly, large-scale battery storage systems, essential for renewable energy, can suffer from thermal runaway leading to fires and explosions. Wind and solar farms present risks such as electrical hazards, mechanical failures, and environmental impacts.
It is critical the team conducting the FSAs understand the unique hazards.
Stage 1 FSAs help prevent hazardous events and protect personnel and assets. Engaging the team actively and addressing potential issues proactively can significantly enhance the effectiveness of Stage 1 FSAs, ensuring the safety and reliability of industrial operations.
Chris Powell, PE, CFSE, is SIS Engineering Group Manager at aeSolutions.

