By Gregory Hale
Whether it is someone on the inside, a nation state, terrorist, or a group making a political statement, critical infrastructure remained a top target for attackers over the second half of last year, a new report found.

In fact, 71 percent of industrial control system (ICS) vulnerabilities disclosed were remotely exploitable through network attack vectors, according to the second Biannual ICS Risk & Vulnerability Report released by industrial cybersecurity company, Claroty. The report also showed a 25 percent increase in ICS vulnerabilities disclosed compared to 2019, as well as a 33 percent increase from 1H 2020.

But to understand those numbers, there needs to be an understanding of where the manufacturing automation sectors stands in terms of equipment usage and its age.

“New products are being more secured and have more security capability, we are seeing product improvement,” said Amir Preminger, vice president of research at Claroty. “But still there is so much legacy equipment; legacy code that was only upgraded to sit on newer platform to support new age protocols like OPC UA, but in its core it is still the same software developed a few years back.”

Schneider Bold

ICS Lifetime
What remains an issue in the ICS sector is the lifetime of a product. In IT you are talking about a much shorter product lifetime compared to OT when you could be looking at 20 to 30 and maybe even 40 years.

“When you implement a switch in IT, it is going to take up until five years,” Preminger said. “When you look at OT, the date you are going to replace the workstation desktop it will probably be after Windows will be end of life, that is the realty of it. The same goes with software. That leads to an even harder problem in OT and that is patching. Patching is so hard because there are so many constraints. Once you find the vulnerabilities, patching them is a hard problem to solve.”

In this era of increased digital connectivity or Industry 4.0, legacy equipment at its very core continues to be a major risk factor.

“The problem is going back to legacy equipment, there is a lot of function still implemented by those basic devices that has been out there for ages, but now we have an intermediate layer that translates those protocols to more advanced 4.0 connectivity,” Preminger said. “In that case, remote access is becoming more and more (of an issue). The problem with Industry 4.0 is it requires more connectivity. Connectivity makes the barrier between IT and OT very small and then everything ends up being exposed. Industry 4.0 introduced a lot of risk, but on the other hand, how would you rate cloud? Cloud in IT introduced a lot of vulnerabilities in to an organization. By itself it did help, but it did bring a lot of risk. You can say the same thing about Industry 4.0. It is worth it? For organizations to keep moving forward, you have to be aware of what you have and invest in good security practices and you can’t ignore it.”

With that in mind, risk will never go away, but it is all about how a company handles it.

Deal with It
“There is not concept of eliminating risk, but you have new technologies coming in and you just have to identify the risk and try to stay up to date with it,” said Chen Fradkin, security researcher at Claroty. “You just have to realize you have to take security into account and actually walk through a strategy like defense-in-depth. It is not about eliminating it, but it is dealing with it.”

The Claroty report consisted of research from its own research team alongside the National Vulnerability Database (NVD), the Industrial Control Systems Cyber Emergency Response Team (ICS-CERT), CERT@VDE, MITRE, and industrial automation vendors Schneider Electric and Siemens.

During the second half of last year 449 vulnerabilities ended up discovered affecting ICS products from 59 vendors. Of those, 70 percent rated high or critical Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS) scores, and 76 percent do not require authentication for exploitation.

“There is a continuous focus on ICS, with a focus on Internet facing devices and remote access,” Preminger said. “There is a lot of focus on companies trying to understand the new attack landscape. We are see more software being reported on. New comer vendors into the CVE domain, which means we are seeing more companies that haven’t had any vulnerabilities reported to them being added to the list of companies being reported.”

New Companies Crop Up
Those new companies that may have a smaller customer set keep adding up.

“In the past half year we had 14 new vendors reported, and the previous year we had 21 new vendors,” Fradkin said. “We saw what was interesting is a majority of them are small vendors.”

As mentioned, critical manufacturing, energy, water and wastewater, and commercial facilities sectors suffered the most from vulnerabilities disclosed during the second half of 2020:

  • Critical manufacturing increased 15 percent from the second half of 2019 and 66 percent from the second half of 2018
  • Energy increased 8 percent from the second half of 2019 and 74 percent from the second half of 2018
  • Water and wastewater increased 54 percent from the second half of 2019 and 63 percent of the second half of 2018
  • Commercial facilities increased 14 percent from the second half of 2019 and 140 percent from the second half of 2018

The number of ICS vulnerabilities disclosed in 2020 increased by more than 30 percent compared to 2018 and nearly 25 percent compared to 2019, according to the report. Two factors contribute to this spike: A heightened awareness of the risks posed by ICS vulnerabilities, and researchers and vendors increasingly focused on identifying and remediating security flaws as effectively and efficiently as possible. This growth indicates security research focused on ICS products maturing.

“Vulnerabilities are part of a lifecycle of any given software,” Preminger said. “It is a question of maturity and we know ICS is not there. There is a lot of low hanging fruit like unsecured passwords being stored. We will continue to see those vulnerabilities.”

Resilient to Attacks
However, if companies continue moving from being aware of the security issue to starting a security program to remain resilient to attacks, they will be able to flourish in this new age of connectivity.

“You need to remove the low barrier attacks, the known attacks,” Preminger said. “As for the unknown attacks, there you need to practice security in layers. A security attack does not start at the end, it starts at the beginning. Like the fortress approach, you need to have different walls and different tactics. You want to get the attacker in different ways.”

Click here to register to download the report.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This