Google Chrome, Microsoft Edge, and Mozilla Firefox were tested for phishing protection and malware Protection running on Windows 10 and 11, according to a non-profit entity dedicated to providing transparency on cybersecurity product efficacy, CyberRatings.org’s 2022 Web Browser Security Test. Key metrics for phishing and malware protection include time to block and protection over time.
The malware tests ran for 24 days with 96 discrete test runs. Phishing tests ran for 20 days with 80 discrete test runs. The reports include measurements of protection against fresh new attacks, consistency of protection over time, and how effective the browser protection was overall, according to the survey.
The ability to warn potential victims they are about to land on a malicious website or click on a suspicious URL puts web browsers in a unique position to protect the user from an attack.
Websites that trick users into downloading malware and phishing campaigns often used for criminal activity have short lifespans, so it is essential that the URL is discovered and added to the reputation system as quickly as possible. A good reputation system must be both accurate and fast to achieve high catch rates.
“Phishing attacks pose a significant risk to individuals and organizations by threatening to compromise or acquire sensitive personal and corporate information,” said Vikram Phatak, chief executive of CyberRatings.org. “Phishing and ransomware attacks continue to rise year over year. Consumers should not override the warnings offered by their web browser protection but instead take advantage of the free offering.”
Key Take-Aways from the survey show:
Malware protection:
Microsoft Edge – 97.0 percent
Google Chrome – 88.4 percent
Mozilla Firefox – 84.6 percent
Phishing protection:
Microsoft Edge – 91.6 percent
Mozilla Firefox – 90.0 percent
Google Chrome – 89.6 percent
Average time to block a URL from malware:
Microsoft Edge 0:56:51
Google Chrome 4:46:39
Mozilla Firefox 5:18:40
Average time to block a phishing URL:
Microsoft Edge 0:44:07
Mozilla Firefox 1:23:37
Google Chrome 2:19:13
The following browsers were tested:
- Google Chrome: Version 101.0.1210.53- 102.0.5005.115
- Microsoft Edge: Version 101.0.1210.47 – 102.0.1254.39
- Mozilla Firefox: Version 100.0.1 – 101.0.1

