In the last few years, the NRC Inspector General reviewed multiple allegations reported regarding the NRC’s oversight at Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant (DCNPP), a plant with two reactors in Avila Beach, California.
Several of those concerns involved the NRC’s oversight of safety-related structures, systems, and components (SSCs). One such SSC is the auxiliary feedwater (AFW) system, which is important to a commercial nuclear power plant because it is a backup water supply that can be used to cool the reactor if normal feedwater is out of service.
Event Inquiry
The Inspector General initiated an event inquiry to review the adequacy of the NRC’s inspections of the AFW system prior to the July 2020 event.
Since the event, the licensee has remedied the AFW system failure and made improvements to the system, and DCNPP continues to operate safely. Additionally, the NRC has since verified the AFW system complies with regulatory requirements, the Inspector General said.
However, during its investigation, the Inspector General found:
- The NRC failed to identify piping insulation that had long been in a degraded condition. This degradation led to a leak in the Unit 2 AFW system piping. As a result, the licensee was required to shut down the unit. At no time during the NRC’s January and April 2020 AFW system inspections or during weekly plant status inspections did the NRC report findings regarding any SSCs that exhibited defects, such as degraded insulation on the AFW system, that would impact function.
- The NRC had not inspected the area where the leak occurred, even though its inspection report indicated inspectors had conducted a complete walkdown of the AFW system in April 2020. A complete walkdown is a physical inspection that verifies the selected system is correctly aligned and able to perform its intended safety function.
- The number of hours NRC staff spent directly inspecting both reactors’ – Units 1 and 2 – AFW systems was fewer (5 hours) than recommended in the applicable NRC inspection procedure (12 hours) for the complete walkdown in April 2020. Senior regional officials acknowledged that the inspection was inadequate.
Areas of Concern
During this inquiry, the Inspector General identified potential areas of concern that could give the appearance of less than optimal regulatory oversight.
The NRC should consider whether it needs to act to ensure:
- NRC inspectors are trained to identify corrosion under insulation and that insulation does not unnecessarily limit their ability to identify such corrosion
- NRC inspection procedures are sufficiently clear and otherwise adequate regarding the expectations for walkdowns, especially with a single unit versus a multiple unit plant
- NRC inspectors are aware of these expectations
- NRC managers are appropriately involved in reviewing whether inspectors follow inspection procedures
- NRC managers are appropriately involved in helping select systems, as well as structures and components within the systems, for inspection
Those are the findings from the Inspector General, however, the NRC does not agree.
“After reviewing the Inspector General’s event inquiry, our technical staff determined that the Reactor Oversight Program and its associated inspection program continue to provide reasonable assurance of adequate protection of public health and safety,” said NRC Executive Director for Operations Dan Dorman. “Resident inspectors are vital to the NRC safety mission. I have full confidence in the qualification, abilities, and professionalism of the inspectors involved in this event inquiry as well as all of our inspectors.”
NRC Response
Among the findings outlined in Dorman’s response:
- The leak in the auxiliary feedwater system did not cause the plant to shut down as stated by the IG, nor did it compromise plant safety. The Diablo Canyon plant has operated safely and continues to do so.
- The staff found no evidence the auxiliary feedwater pipe corrosion hidden under metal jacketed insulation should have been identified by NRC inspectors before the leak occurred. The resident inspectors then assigned to Diablo Canyon followed appropriate guidance during their inspection of the system and regional and headquarters management appropriately determined the leak had very low safety significance.
- Corrosion under insulation, which caused this leak, is known to the industry and the NRC.
- The agency remains confident in the effectiveness of its inspection program, which is one of many ways in which it verifies nuclear power plant safety. Other methods include Reactor Oversight Program performance indicators, rigorous plant licensing requirements, robust design margins for every plant, redundant safety systems that provide defense in depth, and operator and training requirements to enable plant operators to respond to equipment malfunctions and unexpected events.
Included in the NRC response is acknowledgement the IG identified opportunities to improve the NRC’s programs and processes and strengthen its inspection program.

