Indian Point Energy Center nuclear power plant would remain safe should there be a potential accident on a 42-inch natural gas pipeline located near the plant, said an expert team of Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff and outside specialists.
In addition, plant owner of the Buchanan, NY, facility, Entergy, should revisit the assumptions it made in its analysis of any kind of potential accident at the facility, the team said.
The team’s safety conclusion is based on two factors. First, the Algonquin Incremental Market (AIM) pipeline located near the facility has a very small chance of rupture near Indian Point, due to the pipeline’s modern construction, quality control and additional “high consequence” requirements for inspection and an integrity management program.
Second, Indian Point’s safety systems sit well outside the potential impact zones for postulated AIM pipeline accident effects such as heat, pressure and projectiles. The team’s analyses also determined any pipeline-related increase in Indian Point’s risk fell below the NRC’s thresholds for prompting additional action.
The team’s report was submitted in response to direction from Margaret M. Doane, the NRC’s executive eirector for operations, following an NRC Inspector General report on the agency’s handling of public concerns about the pipeline issues.
Potential Hazards
The team reviewed how Entergy and the NRC analyzed potential hazards from the proposed AIM pipeline in 2014, as well as how the NRC processed a public stakeholder’s petitions for enforcement action related to the pipeline.
The team recommended Entergy update the assumptions used in its analysis with the new information the team developed during its review. The team also recommended several improvements to NRC processes related to the conduct of technical reviews, peer review, inspection support, interagency cooperation and public petition processing.
The NRC intends to hold a public meeting near the plant regarding the report when the region has sufficiently recovered from the COVID-19 public health emergency.
The team included experts in NRC engineering reviews and probabilistic risk analysis, as well as a Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration safety expert. The team also incorporated important insights from researchers at Sandia National Laboratories with expertise on natural gas modeling and fire risk. All team members were independent of those performing prior reviews regarding the AIM pipeline and its potential effects on Indian Point. The team’s work was peer-reviewed by a mechanical engineering expert from the NRC’s independent Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards.
Optimistic Assumptions
The team determined that, even though Entergy (the plant owner) and the NRC made some optimistic assumptions in analyzing potential rupture of the 42-inch natural gas transmission pipeline, the Indian Point reactors remain safe. The team drew two key conclusions related to this statement.
- A rupture of the newly installed 42-inch natural gas transmission pipeline that runs near Indian Point is unlikely. As mentioned, this pipeline ended up installed using modern techniques, stringent quality standards, and construction precautions that limit the likelihood of later pipeline damage. This stretch of pipeline was designated as a high consequence area under Department of Transportation requirements, meaning additional inspection, integrity threat assessment, pipe remediation, and documentation requirements apply. Given the remaining operating life of Units 2 and 3 (mere weeks to a year, respectively), the risk of a pipeline rupture affecting the reactor units is very small.
- If a rupture occurred on the stretch of 42-inch pipeline near Indian Point, the nuclear power plant would remain protected. The plant’s safety systems are all far from the pipeline. They are two or more times the “potential impact radius” the U.S. Department of Transportation designates for protecting people from pipeline ruptures and also far outside the distance where heat flux would be high enough to affect wooden structures, let alone the robust concrete structures that house the plant’s safety equipment. The potential impact radius bounds most pipe rupture impacts observed in real-life accidents. In a more detailed transient analysis, the team found the robust concrete structures housing the plant’s safety-related equipment, spent fuel pool, and dry fuel storage containers would withstand the heat and pressure impacts of an explosion or fire that could follow a pipeline explosion. The safety-related equipment would be able to safely shut down the reactors and maintain them in a safe shutdown condition. Equipment or structures outside these buildings could end up affected, but these serve as backups or alternatives to the safety-related equipment.
Decommissioning Plan
Indian Point is in the process of undergoing decommissioning this year and next.
One of the two operating reactors at the plant, Unit 2, is scheduled to permanently cease operations in late April. The other, Unit 3, will be taken offline for the last time in April 2021. The Unit 1 reactor permanently shut down in 1974 and has been in long-term storage since then, awaiting eventual decommissioning.

