By Gregory Hale
Line 4 at the Gainesville, Georgia, poultry plant was experiencing unresolved operational issues on the chicken conveyor that may have resulted in the accidental release of liquid nitrogen in the flash freezing bath which led to the death of six workers and the injury of 12 others, federal officials said Sunday.

On the day of the tragedy, line 4 of the five production line system at the Foundation Food Group’s Plant 4 was shut down due to operational issues on the conveyor line, said investigators at the Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB) regarding the lethal January 28 liquid nitrogen (LN) release.

Foundation Food Group maintenance personnel reported the computerized measuring system indicated a low liquid level in the immersion bath used to flash freeze the chicken products, CSB officials said.

Using LN ended up introduced to Plant 4 last year, and it was also seeing use on line 2. The system installed on line 4 is a LN immersion-spiral freezer. This process occurs in two stages. In the first stage, the chicken travels on a conveyer belt and is submerged in LN at a temperature of -320F. In the second stage, the conveyer belt travels through the spiral freezer portion, and the chicken undergoes exposure to recovered gaseous nitrogen (from stage 1), to complete the freezing process.

Schneider Bold

Unplanned Maintenance
Unplanned maintenance was being conducted on the Line 4 immersion freezer at the time of the deadly nitrogen leak. After the incident occurred, investigators found tools located on the ground around the leaking equipment. In addition, major portions of the liquid nitrogen system at the Foundation Food Group poultry processing center ended up installed and commissioned in the last 4 to 6 weeks on Line 4 in Plant 4 at the facility.

The external and the interior elements of this system were manufactured and owned by Messer, including the supply tanks outside, and the interior cryogenic freezing equipment on line 4.

Prior to the installation and commissioning of this system 4 to 6 weeks ago, a different type of freezing equipment was used, which was ammonia-based. This equipment is still collocated on line 4 adjacent to the cryogenic system and has not yet been removed.

While the equipment was installed made by Messer, Foundation Food Group, which leased the equipment, performed routine maintenance.

While the plant had been experiencing unresolved operational issues on the chicken conveyor, the line was shut down the morning of the incident. The shutdown was due to operational issues on the conveyor line, CSB officials said. As mentioned, Foundation Food Group maintenance personnel reported the computerized measuring system indicated a low liquid level in the immersion bath used to flash freeze the chicken products.

At 10:15 a.m. January 28, multiple 911 emergency calls reported an incident at Foundation Food Group’s Prepared Foods Division, Plant 4, in Gainesville, GA, said Dr. Katherine Lemos, chairman and chief executive of the CSB.

The victims, all employees of Foundation Food Group in Gainesville, are Jose DeJesus Elias-Cabrera, 45; Corey Alan Murphy, 35; Nelly Perez-Rafael, 28; Saulo Suarez-Bernal, 41; Victor Vellez, 38; and Edgar Vera-Garcia, 28, the Hall County Sheriff’s Office said. In addition to the fatalities and hospitalizations, there were 130 evacuees. CSB officials said one remaining patient, who was once in critical condition, is now in fair condition.

Hall County Sherriff, Gerald Couch, confirmed five employees died at the scene, and emergency personnel transported others to Northeast Georgia Medical Center. One of those employees died later at the hospital.

Chaos During Incident
Jameel Fareed, one of 130 employees evacuated from the plant Thursday morning, told Atlanta’s Channel 2 Action News the nitrogen leak set off chaos in the plant.

“First we just thought there was something wrong with the freezer, then they started saying get out,” Fareed said. “I just saw the fog and when I couldn’t see down the steps, I turned around. But I didn’t feel anything.”

Another worker said colleagues started pushing each other to get out.

Poultry plants use refrigeration systems that often include liquid nitrogen, which vaporizes into an odorless gas capable of displacing oxygen when leaked. Liquid nitrogen is colorless, odorless and extremely cold. It can cause serious damage and quick death with no warning. The gas can cause extensive tissue damage or burns. Inhaling large amounts of nitrogen can cause dizziness, nausea, vomiting, loss of consciousness and death.

For some reason not known yet, there was a release of liquid nitrogen, which rapidly converted to a gas. This gas is heavier than air, and forces oxygen out of the room, Lemos said.

In the facility, a cryogenic freezer and associated equipment houses and disperses the liquid nitrogen. However, the liquid nitrogen ends up stored in tanks external to the building, in the parking lot. The maintenance manager described personally closing the isolation valves of the tanks in the parking lot after the incident, shutting off supply to the building, which limited the potential damage for the event, Lemos said. Investigators are currently working to understand the exact location of the point of release inside the plant, Lemos said.

Plant 4 receives 2-3 18-wheel truckloads per day of liquid nitrogen.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This