A subsea technician sustained an eye injury while working on the hands-free gooseneck (HFGN) during well operations for LLOG Exploration Offshore, L.L.C. (LLOG) at Keathley Canyon Block 686.

The severity of the eye injury required evacuation of the Seadrill West Neptune subsea technician from the rig on the next regularly scheduled flight for a medical evaluation, according to an investigation from the Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement (BSEE).

On August 7, 2019, the Seadrill subsea team was conducting the initial latch-up pressure and function testing of the subsea blowout preventer equipment (BOPE).

As the Seadrill subsea team was conducting the low-pressure test on the choke and kill lines, fluid was observed leaking from the boost line HFGN stab, according to the report. Upon further investigation of the leak, fluid was discovered flowing from the area between the tension ring housing and the HFGN ring suggesting a leaking choke or kill poly-pack seal. The Seadrill subsea team then attempted to retract the HFGN stabs from the telescopic joint to unlock and lower the tensioner ring to access the poly-pack seals.

However, the HFGN choke and kill line stab locks failed to retract, according to the report. The Seadrill subsea team loosened the bolts on the tail rod flanges which allowed the HFGN locking assembly to move into the unlock position enabling the rods on the choke line to retract without incident. The Seadrill subsea team began repeating this process for the kill line HFGN locking pins with the Seadrill subsea technician positioned in a personnel maintenance basket.

Schneider Bold

High Pressure Ejection
The Seadrill subsea technician then unbolted and removed the kill line lock assembly, according to the document. As he was turning around in the personnel maintenance basket, the indicator rod ended up ejected by a combination of air and water pressure from within the operator housing. The indicator rod struck the Seadrill subsea technician in his right eye causing his safety glasses to be pushed back into his face contacting his eyebrow. The indicator rod continued to travel past the subsea supervisor and toolpusher, who were standing four feet away from the operation, and landed on the upper moon pool platform. The Seadrill subsea technician was lowered in the personnel maintenance basket and taken to the rig medic for treatment.

After treatment, the technician evacuated on the next regularly scheduled helicopter flight for a medical evaluation at Bourgeois Medical Clinic in Morgan City, Louisiana.

Sheared Indicator rod ejected from Hands-Free Goose Neck (HFGN) cartridge operator striking a subsea technician’s safety glasses.Source: BSEE

The next day, on August 8, the Seadrill subsea technician ended up diagnosed with orbital fractures and bruising around his right eye.

The doctor released the Seadrill subsea technician on restricted duty and he finished out his hitch at Seadrill’s Office in Houston, Texas.

LLOG verbally reported this incident to the BSEE Lafayette District Inspectors at 8 a.m. on August 7 who were on the rig at the time of the incident to witness the subsea BOPE pressure and function testing. BSEE inspectors gathered all available documentation, including a preliminary report and photographs, prior to departure from the rig at 1:22 p.m. that day.

Previous Issue
Based on Seadrill’s incident investigation report, the Seadrill West Neptune personnel knew the choke and kill indicator rods had been found to have sheared from the de-coupling segments inside the HFGN cartridge operators. Seadrill documented the broken equipment case on an internal “out of service” excel report dated on December 17, 2018. The equipment was outside the Original Equipment Manufactures (OEM) guidelines, according to the BSEE document. The Seadrill West Neptune equipment issue was not reported.

The Seadrill incident investigation report also said the Seadrill West Neptune personnel created a temporary work around until the HFGN assembly was fixed. ‘An additional step was created to slacken or remove the locking assembly mounting plate to allow the locking bar clearance over the protruding indicator rod allowing the locking bar to be extended.’ The additional step with the known broken equipment was not performed within the OEM guidelines.

The Seadrill team encountered unexpected trapped hydrostatic pressure in the choke and kill lines. The dangerous pressure was not accounted for during pressure tests. BSEE recommended revising the bleed down procedures to accommodate for the trapped pressure.

The BSEE incident investigation team has determined the probable causes of the incident was because of:

  • Human performance Error – Not following proper procedures by operating out of compliance equipment. Seadrill did not follow OEM operational guidelines since they knowingly operated the out of compliance equipment since December 2018 because they failed to report that the indicator rods had sheared inside the cartridge operators
  • Human performance Error – Not following proper procedures to correct issue. By not following OEM operational recommendations, Seadrill created an unsafe walkaround procedure to accommodate for out of compliant equipment
  • Human Performance Error – Not aware of Hazards. The crew failed to recognize the presence of trapped pressure hazards when removing the locking assembly mounting plate.

Improper Placement
A contributing factor to the incident, according to BSEE is a human performance error in an improper body placement. The Seadrill subsea technician manually disengaged the locks to function the choke and kill stabs that placed him in the position to be struck by the sheared indicator rod.

Based on the incident investigation findings, a G-110 Incident of Noncompliance (INC) ended up issued to LLOG Exploration Offshore to document its failure to protect health, safety and the environment by performing operations in an unsafe and unworkmanlike manner on the Seadrill West Neptune drill ship.

BSEE recommends operators and contractors consider the following:

  1. Maintain equipment in accordance with OEM specifications
  2. Follow proper procedures when performing work orders
  3. Do not use out of service equipment
  4. Do not create work-around procedures for out of service equipment
  5. Always be cognizant of potential trapped pressure and note this as a hazard on procedures and job safety analysis

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This