Every Operation has a Critical Component to Protect
By Gregory Hale
A cyber attack occurs and the first thing all experts think about is protecting the critical infrastructure, and deservedly so, but an equally key aspect is understanding and protecting the critical infrastructure for manufacturers within non-critical infrastructure industries.

A definition of critical infrastructure from the Department of Homeland Security is the physical and cyber systems and assets that are so vital their incapacity or destruction would have a debilitating impact on our physical or economic security or public health or safety. Examples of debilitating attacks came across the globe when there were two separate attacks in the Ukraine in December of 2015 and in 2016 where the grid ended up shut down for a period of time.

However, if you take the idea of critical infrastructure to a more micro level, there are elements within any operation that is critical in the sense if something were to happen to those operations — if there was any disruption — that it could incapacitate the entire operation. So, along those lines, every manufacturer has a critical infrastructure within its operation.

“Within an operation, there are certain elements that are critical,” said Nasir Mundh, senior director commercial global cybersecurity services at Schneider Electric. “Even if it’s an assembly line, even if it’s a molding line or even if it’s a packaging line for that matter, any one of those could be very critical from that business’ perspective. If something were to happen to that part of the business, their entire chain would stop, and they wouldn’t get production out and it would critically impact business continuity. Even within that part, there are certain critical elements. For example, when we talked about the larger macro level, critical infrastructure is your electricity generation power distribution. When you get down to an operation like a button manufacturer, that same critical infrastructure on a micro level is their electricity supply. It’s their power management. It’s their air handling unit. Within the context of that business, those are critical infrastructure albeit at a micro level. They need to understand those things are critical to run the business continuously.”

Ransomware Attacks
Mundh said he has seen an increase in attacks and cyber activity with one of the major types of attacks for critical and non-critical infrastructure companies being ransomware.

“When you look at critical infrastructure, the intent could be either the intent to get some commercial benefit out of it, or just to cause disruption for whatever reason,” Mundh said. “But when you look at the commercial side of it, even if it’s non-critical infrastructure per se, ransomware is an issue.”

One study reiterated what Mundh had to say as there has been an increase in WastedLocker ransomware activity this year, which is going after industries such as utilities and energy, manufacturing, high tech, engineering, and pharmaceutical and life sciences, said researchers at Palo Alto Networks’ Unit 42.

In addition, attackers are also going after transportation and logistics, professional and legal services, and wholesale and retail, the researchers said.

Schneider Bold

“The commercial impact of ransomware, we see so much of that coming in, day in, day out, that you see it across all industry, doesn’t have to be the larger electricity producers or large petrochemical plant for large infrastructure,” Mundh said. “It could be any business that could be disrupted. People make money out of being hackers and that could apply anywhere. Car manufacturers could face it and it could be anybody.”

IT-OT Convergence
Ransomware is also another fallout of companies working in the COVID-19 era, which means companies need to intensify convergence of information technology (IT) and operational technology (OT).

Along those lines, COVID-19 has accelerated the convergence of IT and OT networks where 67 percent of survey respondents said their IT and OT networks have become more interconnected since the pandemic began, and more than 75 percent expect they will become even more so as a result, according to a report released by security provider, Claroty, entitled, “The Critical Convergence of IT and OT Security in a Global Crisis.”

The report also said disparities between IT and OT remain with 66 percent finding collaboration between IT and OT teams more challenging during the pandemic, while 62 percent believe their organization’s IT and OT networks are not equally secure.

Mundh said there are multiple ways companies have of looking at convergence.

Levels and Approaches
“It depends on the maturity level people have within organizations. You can go in there and you can see people say, ‘Hey, yep. IT is current, IT is protected. I’m good. There is no need for cybersecurity around OT.’ Second would be, yes, OT is an issue, but I’m in the IT department, IT department takes care of this, OT department takes care of that and the two shall never talk to each other. And then you have the more mature customers who have realized you can’t just separate them. Even if it’s not a full convergence for us, per se, but there is still connectivity.

“The more advanced customers, they are realizing that they come to the conclusion that I have the best, the most sophisticated protection system on my IT network. But when I go down to my control network, I have zero visibility. They understand the IT protocols. But when it comes to industrial protocols, they don’t. But the realization has started. Now, people have moving more and more toward a holistic scope. Again, if the customers are more mature, they have come to the realization, they have convinced their people, they know what the impact could be to their business.”

The end result is critical or non-critical, any manufacturer has a critical component to their business and the need to protect it to keep it up and running remains paramount to business continuity.

 

Best Practices for Non-Critical Manufacturers

Whether it is critical infrastructure or a non-critical industry, any company could use an idea on what practices they should conduct to reduce or mitigate breaches or intrusions.

“The most important thing is for them to have visibility,” said Nasir Mundh, senior director commercial global cybersecurity services at Schneider Electric. “Visibility on their network of what’s going on; that’s a very key element. What’s your level of traffic? What is your baseline? What should be normal? And then have the capability to look at normal and be able to pick up anything that’s abnormal, anything that’s anomalous, any traffic that doesn’t conform to the regular pattern, they should have that visibility.”

Having visibility is key, but that is not the only answer.

“They also need technical controls like authentication, endpoint protection, backup, network segmentation, in addition they have to have the right processes and the right governance controls as well.

“They need to know things like how authentication is actually going to work. What’s the philosophy around patch management? How are the backups going to be backed up? All that governance. How are they going to manage third-party risk? How are they going to manage their suppliers? In the case of a button manufacturer, how are they going to make sure they are managing their suppliers and that entire supply chain? Is there entire supply chain secure? How much of their factory is a smart factory? Who’s talking to who? What’s that traffic going on? They have to put in policies and procedures. They have to understand what their risks are. And then, based on those risks, put in governance control, how it’s going to run and actual technical controls using technologies that are available that give them not only that visibility, but the controls that are put in place.”

It also comes down to people that understand the deployment plan and remain trained and understand the policies and procedures, the governance, and the technical controls, and then they have visibility over that control. They also need to keep monitoring and put in place a continuous improvement plan, so cybersecurity is not static, but a continuous evolving project.

— Gregory Hale

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This