Two water and wastewater treatment facilities in rural Maine suffered separate ransomware attacks earlier this year.

The first attack occurred in April in Mount Desert and the second broke out on the Fourth of July in Limestone. While the attacks did occur, no money was paid and no customer data suffered compromise.

“It’s like an arms race between the good guys and the bad guys,” said Mount Desert Town Manager Durlin Lunt Jr. in a published report. “Fortunately, in this case, they didn’t get anything.”

In northern Maine, Limestone was hit on the Fourth of July holiday. Limestone Water and Sewer District Superintendent Jim Leighton said the control computer was hit with the ransomware attack.

The hackers couldn’t cause harm to the process, but the computer shutdown did take out alarms to alert workers if pumps overheat or tanks are overfilled, Leighton said.

Schneider Bold

Outdated Computer
The facility was using a Windows 7 computer which was well past its end of life date and was due to be replaced anyway, he said. In the end, it may have been a good thing because it caught the attention of water and sewage district operators in Aroostook County, he said.

“We said enough of that, it’s not worth paying a ransom for,” he continued. “We had to update it anyway.”

“It was a bad thing for us but a good thing for the county,” he said. “Everyone took notice and did things to their computers so they couldn’t be hit.”

The April attack occurred in the town of Mount Desert on Mount Desert Island, said Judy Bruenjes, a wastewater technical assistance engineer for the state Department of Environmental Protection (DEP).

In Mount Desert Island, officials said the attack took computers offline for three days, but treatment plants were not affected because they are controlled manually.

“They were both fairly minor, there was no threat to the public, there was no violation, no excursion, no health and safety threat. It wasn’t like the Colonial pipeline, but it was a concern for us that these small facilities were being targeted,” Bruenjes said.

A May 7 attack on Georgia-based Colonial Pipeline shut down operations after the IT enterprise suffered the assault. The resulting shutdown led to panic buying in the Southeast which emptied gas stations of fuel and left some motorists waiting hours to fuel up their vehicles.

Colonial paid an estimated $4.4 million ransom, most of which was recovered by the Justice Department. The FBI has blamed the attack on a Russia-based gang of hackers using the DarkSide ransomware variant.

Didn’t Pay Ransom
“It is encouraging that the wastewater plant was able to recover from the attack without having to pay the ransom,” said Syed Belal, Hexagon PPM’s director of OT cybersecurity consulting services. “The ransomware industry is currently built upon a solid business case – this blight will continue as long as the perpetrators can get a return on their investment. Companies should increase their investments on improving business resiliency so they can minimize the impact of an attack and restore operations within a reasonable time. Mount Desert in Maine should be lauded for their ability to recover operations without paying the ransom.

“These attacks also reinforce the message that just because you’re not Colonial Pipeline, that doesn’t mean you’re not a target. This should be a wake-up call for smaller infrastructure entities, and small businesses across all industries, that they’re still attractive to attackers and they need to prepare like their networks are about to be compromised.”

In a July 8 memo, a Maine water management director disclosed the attacks and warned of their danger.

“Unfortunately, this is real. It has happened in Maine and it is likely to happen again,” said Brian Kavanah, director of Maine’s Bureau of Water Quality. “It is imperative for facilities to take action to verify their systems are secure before becoming a victim of cyberattacks.”

Kavanah included directions for municipalities to seek American Rescue Plan funding to bolster their systems, along with resources for cybersecurity training for Maine water plant operators. Obtaining a wastewater operator license in Maine does not require any form of cybersecurity training.

Officials in Limestone traced their attack to a computer running an outdated Windows 7 that was connected to the plant’s supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) system.

Down 3 Days
Ed Montague, superintendent for Mount Desert Wastewater, said, “The office computers were down for approximately three working days… Our treatment plants were not affected as they are manually controlled with no automated inputs.” No ransom was paid and no personal information was compromised, Montague said, and town and IT professionals were notified.

It is easy to point fingers and say a wastewater facility should continually upgrade its systems, but towns can struggle to find the time and money for software upgrades and training.

“They may not have the most up-to-date software. They’re vulnerable,” Bruenjes said. “We’re concerned about smaller systems.”

Another public attack occurred in February at the Oldsmar, Florida, water system, where an attacker remotely accessed a computer for the city’s water treatment system and briefly increased the amount of sodium hydroxide, or lye, by a factor of more than 100, from 100 parts per million to 11,100 parts per million. Thanks to an operator who witnessed the attack going on, he was able to quickly change the setting back to 100 parts per million.

Most ransomware attacks come through email, which means any system that has not been properly patched or updated could be vulnerable.

In the case of the most recent attack in Limestone, Maine, “One of them was a desktop computer that was hooked up with the network and one of them was the main computer with Windows 7 that was aligned with the SCADA system,” Bruenjes said. Leighton said it would cost roughly $10,000 to upgrade the system.

Often at small water facilities, there is a dearth of training for workers not only in terms of budgets, but also for finding the time in a short-staffed work environment.

There is no specific cybersecurity training requirement in order for someone to obtain a wastewater operators license, said Bruenjes, although the DEP and others offer ongoing training. A variety of federal and state organizations offer assistance to communities, and some funding for equipment and technology upgrades is available via the Clean Water State Revolving Fund.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This