By Gregory Hale
Ransomware will hit the other guy and not me. Why should anyone go after my company, we are just a quiet manufacturer that just keeps producing our critical product. No need to worry on our part.
While that thinking is prevalent across the industry, it is just plain wrong.
Ransomware is not new as it has been in the industry for quite some time, but attacks targeting industrial organizations are now reaching new heights and no organization is immune. On a global basis, an 80 percent of respondents in a global survey by industrial security provider Claroty said they experienced an attack, and 47 percent said it impacted the OT/ICS environment.
Global Survey
Claroty conducted an independent, global survey of 1,100 information technology (IT) and operational technology (OT) security professionals who work full time for enterprises that own, operate, or otherwise support components of critical infrastructure.
In industries including IT hardware, oil and gas, water and wastewater, and automotive, 90 percent felt the impact of ransomware and 87 percent suffered in heavy industry and electric energy. In doing simple supply side economics, the larger the organization, the more likely an attack because that is where the money is. However, with the number may be smaller 63 percent of small to medium businesses with less than $500M annual revenue report being impacted by ransomware.
For organizations that experienced a ransomware attack, the financial impact was significant.
In a move that goes against advice from security professionals and government alike, on a global basis, over 60 percent said they paid the ransom, and, of those, 52 percent paid $500,000 or more. The U.S. led the way, where 76 percent paid the ransom and 57 percent paid $500,000 or more, versus 51 percent that paid in APAC and 49 percent in Europe. Payouts also trended lower in those regions, concentrated in the $100,000 to $500,000 range.
What’s driving this decision to pay the ransom? Regardless of region, a majority of respondents estimated a loss in revenue per hour of downtime to their operations equal to or greater than the payout. So, the financial model seems to favor paying the ransom given this equation and what’s at stake. This reasoning is also likely why on a global basis 69 percent of respondents believe it should be legal to pay ransoms.
Ransomware Payments
“The government says do not pay, do not pay, do not pay,” Antova said.” Why are over 60 percent paying the ransom? They are paying the ransom because critical systems are being held hostage. That means the organization as a whole needs to make a decision.
“Big businesses are a much more interesting targets because the human behind the ransomware attack is looking for an emotional quick response. The bigger the business, the more critical and more interconnected, the better chance you as an attacker have in getting a response,” she said.
In addition to the huge amount of organizations suffering from ransomware attacks and the large amount deciding to pay, over 90 percent of attacked organizations disclosed the incident to shareholders and/or authorities, and reported the impact was substantial or significant in 49 percent of the cases.
Industrial organizations dealt with significant challenges in 2021. Cyberattacks on the Oldsmar, Florida water facility; ransomware attacks on Colonial Pipeline, and JBS; supply chain attacks at SolarWinds and Kaseya all launched industrial cybersecurity to the national and global stage.
Millions of people have woken up to the financial (up to $40 million paid in one ransomware attack) and societal repercussions (a panic rush on gasoline that closed down stations across the Southeast United States) when critical infrastructure is disrupted. On top of this, business leaders continue to deal with the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic while determining how to operate efficiently and securely. All that said, organizations need to stay on top of their security games and remain resilient.
Respondents across regions consistently and overwhelmingly rank implementing new technology solutions as the top priority, with respondents in oil and gas and IT hardware tilting the ranking at 57 percent and 49 percent respectively. That said, Europe lists training as a close second and SMBs prioritize training and technology equally at the top.
“We are running faster than we ever have, but adversaries are getting into our networks at a higher rate than ever before,” Antova said. “Digital transformation and more connectivity means there are more ways to get in. But you also have to think about the motivation for the attackers who know OT networks and critical infrastructure are critical.
Urgency to Pay
“Attackers know different levels of urgency drive different behaviors. Part of it is attackers have figured out where to go for the ‘critical valuable networks’ which is where they are getting humans to react the fastest,” Antova said.
Over the years, the industrial cybersecurity industry has made tremendous progress in creating solutions that help eliminate blind spots and close security gaps to build resilience.
The following five recommended technologies and processes can help security leaders and their teams better protect their OT environments and enable the business in today’s hyperconnected world.
Extend risk governance to include cyber-physical assets. Devices that are not designed with security in mind introduce risk when connected to IT and OT networks. This includes all Industrial IoT, ICS, and Enterprise IoT components. Extending governance to include these assets is a challenging step for many organizations since it’s not an easy task to even identify them. It’s a process that might take iterations.
Maintain proper segmentation. There are business processes and applications that need to communicate across the IT/OT boundary, so organizations need to ensure this is done in a secure way. Ensuring an organization’s OT network and assets are isolated from IT in a manner that aligns with segmentation best practices can be a highly effective means of stopping the lateral spread of ransomware and other malware from IT to OT. In addition to segmentation between IT and OT networks, deploy virtual segmentation to zones within the OT environment.
Practice good cyber hygiene. Ensure cyber hygiene extends to OT and IoT devices. This includes the use of strong passwords (and not sharing passwords amongst different users), a password vault, and multi-factor authentication. Some processes, like patching legacy systems, might be more challenging or not possible. If that is the case, identify and implement compensating controls such as firewall rules and access control lists.
Implement a robust system monitoring program. Being able to monitor for threats in IT and OT networks and anything that is traversing that boundary is imperative for effective and efficient detection and response. Agentless solutions purpose-built for continuous threat monitoring across the OT network, can be implemented quickly, integrate equally well with OT and IT systems and workflows, and allow IT and OT teams to look at OT environments together.
Assess and build preparedness. Implementing the above capabilities and strengthening resilience gives security leaders and teams peace of mind. Running tabletop exercises of ransomware attacks provides a deeper understanding of organizational and technical preparedness. This affords organizations an opportunity to create an improved incident response plan that will build confidence in preparedness and in-the-moment decision making, and resilience to such attacks. If not already in place, formalize partnerships with incident response and legal firms.
“Defenders don’t have visibility, attackers are very opportunistic, and unfortunately we are going through turbulent times as the pandemic forced us to accelerate the digital transformation measures,” Antova said. “The benefits will outweigh the risks. In order to have a chance in today competitive world as an organization, you have to take security very seriously and bake it into any digital transformation plans you have or otherwise you are dead on arrival.”
Click here to register to download the full report.


