A chilling safety video details the moments and mistakes made before the fatal release of acetic acid at the LyondellBasell La Porte Complex in La Porte, Texas, on July 27, 2021, that killed two contract workers and injured another.

At the time of the incident, 164,000 pounds of a highly corrosive acetic acid mixture erupted from equipment when three contract workers inadvertently removed critical components of a plug valve, according to a report from the Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB). All three workers ended up sprayed with the acetic acid mixture. Two of the workers, Dustin Day and Shawn Kuhleman died from their injuries.

The CSB’s new safety video, called “Designed to Fail: Chemical Release at LyondellBasell,” includes an animation of the events leading to the incident. LyondellBasell’s La Porte Complex is the third largest acetic acid producer in the world. The acid is also a corrosive liquid that can cause severe skin burns and eye damage upon exposure and can be harmful if inhaled.

Not the First Time
“Unfortunately, this is not the first time that simple maintenance of a plug valve ended in tragedy. Our report and recommendations aim to help prevent incidents like this one from reoccurring,” said CSB Board Member Dr. Sylvia Johnson.

The CSB released its final investigation report on the fatal LyondellBasell incident on May 25, 2023. The CSB’s investigation found the incident occurred when three contractors from Turn2 Specialties Companies attempted to isolate a pipe section located between a leaking pipe and an acetic acid reactor.

Schneider Bold

To do so, they decided to lock a plug valve in the closed position by removing the valve’s actuator. Before the incident, Turn2, a contractor hired by LyondellBasell said it had qualified personnel qualified and available to remove the actuator.

However, LyondellBasell did not have a procedure detailing how to remove the actuator, and neither LyondellBasell nor Turn2 trained the Turn2 personnel on how to remove the actuator, according to the report.

Instead, the contractors inadvertently removed pressure-retaining fasteners that were holding the valve cover in place. As a result, the  compromised valve failed, and all three Turn2 workers ended up sprayed by the acetic acid mixture.

Key Safety Issues
The safety video addresses two key safety issues identified in the CSB’s final report: (1) valve design to prevent human error and (2) providing workers with conditions, procedures, and training to safely conduct work.

Video shows workers attempting to loosen actuator before the pressure released the over 160,000 pounds of acetic acid.Source: CSB screen capture

“The best way to address this type of incident would be by prevention through design of new plug valves,” said and CSB Investigator Benjamin Schrader. “But in the meantime, facilities should clearly label pressure containing components on existing plug valves for example through color-coded paint and warning signs so that workers can identify them more easily.”

Schrader went on to say, at some facilities, a risk assessment may determine that depressurizing and deinventorying equipment should be mandatory before removing plug valve actuating equipment.”

In short, LyondellBasell did not have procedure in place to remove the actuator, thinking it was a very simple task.

“As this tragic incident has shown us, even a simple task can turn deadly if it is not properly performed. It is time to improve the design of plug valves and take other protective actions, such as ensuring that clear markings are visible on all existing plug valve pressure-retaining components, and workers are properly trained before conducting maintenance. Vital steps like these can go a long way in injury prevention and help save lives.”

Click here to view the video.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This