By Gregory Hale
When it comes to security in the manufacturing automation sector, it is not just about IT or OT, it also includes elements like building automation and physical security.
“What NotPetya showed everybody is you don’t have to be targeted,” said Dawn Cappelli, vice president, global security and chief information security officer at Rockwell Automation during a meeting at the Rockwell Automation Fair in Chicago, IL, Tuesday. “Bigger companies understand the bigger leveraged attacks. Attacks are coming in from IT into OT. It is more than IT and OT it is also building automation, physical, it is every part of the manufacturing enterprise. We have to secure the whole enterprise eco-system.”
The entire enterprise eco-system means an increasingly connected environment, which means security has to be deeply involved.
“To have a connected enterprise, security has to be embedded,” said Chris Nardecchia, senior vice president and chief digital and information officer at Rockwell Automation. “If you want to leverage your data, you will have to do it in a secure way.”
Manufacturing is headed to a more digital, if not all digital environment, but what happens like in the case of the two attacks in Ukraine or at Norsk Hydro, where the organizations, after having suffered from an attack, had to go manual to get back up and running.
“IT-OT convergence is driven by a couple of things, one is cybersecurity in general and the second is digital transformation,” Nardecchia said. “They are both top of mind subjects. Creating a technological architecture with specific security zones can help. You would have to be able to decouple yourself, but to still be able to operate is a design consideration.”
“We are talking to more IT folks today than OT and they are more senior staff,” said Dave Weinstein, chief security officer at Claroty in a separate meeting. “That just demonstrates how the issue has elevated beyond the plant floor. CISOs are now bringing on OT specialists.
“We need to use visibility to do certain things like create zones on the plant floor,” Cappelli said.
With IT and OT coming together the relationship between the different departments is getting better, but there are still issues with each trying to understand what the other is all about.
When it comes to security, Cappelli said they all learned from the NIST Framework.
“We use the NIST Framework,” she said. “We walked through the framework. We did that with IT security, physical security, and OT security. We found, here is where we are really good – and here are the gaps. We are still going a strategic roadmap three years later. IT and OT have to understand each other and respect each other.”
“We have to have leadership to show it is an important thing to come together,” Nardecchia said. “It really helps having OT experience. It also helps having IT people in manufacturing environment. Cross training can help develop a level of trust.”
The IT and OT relationship “has not developed as quickly as I had hoped,” Weinstein said. “There are cultural barriers that still have to come down and there are conflicts in priorities. They are reconciling security with availability and uptime.”

