By Gregory Hale
An industrial control system is a very complex set of systems that relies on devices to communicate with other devices to show just what is happening on the plant floor.
Protocol gateways play an important role to ensure communication flows to ensure a smooth running process. While the devices themselves may have vulnerabilities that need patching every once in a while. But what about protocol translations?
“The common understanding is the devices are tiny, cheap, embedded piece of hardware and it performs secondary tasks, but in reality they can actually run a full fledge system and it actually is core to the industrial network,” said Marco Balduzzi, Ph.D., senior research scientist at Trend Micro Research during his talk Wednesday at the Blackhat USA 2020 Virtual Conference.
With the development of the Industry 4.0, legacy devices like serial control servers or PLCs often need to connect to modern IT networks, or to the Internet. Along those lines, protocol gateways enable an IP-based network to connect one or more serial devices.
There is no doubt protocol gateways suffer from their own operating-system vulnerabilities, but what is not clear is if protocol conversion is resilient to attacks. Balduzzi’s Trend Micro team conducted a cross-vendor security evaluation of five popular gateways and discovered several classes of security problems that, when leveraged by attackers, can damage or have a negative impact on the operation of industrial facilities.
“We wanted to understand the problems when it comes to the translation capabilities of these devices and how these problems are manufactured in the real world,” Balduzzi said. “We wanted to look at the translation to understand how the protocol translated into another protocol and do an analysis and prevent a disruption in the translation.”
For his research Balduzzi said the team, which consisted of colleagues Philippe Lin, Ryan Flores, Charles Perine, Rainer Vosseler and external researcher Luca Bongiorni, wanted to focus on Modbus because it is widely used protocol and it covers the control network and the field network.
After showing a series of attacks and translation issues, like authenticated privilege escalation, memory leakage, and leaking of memory data, Balduzzi showed protocol conversion was vulnerable to attacks.
“All these types of attacks are all possible. If an attacker knows more about what sits on the back of the protocol gateway and knows more about the mapping table, he can perform a more targeted attack and not do a blind attack,” he said.
In addition to the Modbus protocol issues, Balduzzi said there were other translation problems related to:
- Cloud translations
- Availability
- Different implementation of the specs
In their research, the team found nine Zero Day vulnerabilities and are currently working with the affected vendors.
When looking at protocol translation, Balduzzi recommended:
1. Consider security as an important aspect in product selection
2. Do not rely on a single point of control/failure
3. Correct configure and manage, even if they are small embedded devices
“Even if they are small and tiny and not as visible, they play a very important role in a modern functioning network and they are core to communications,” he said. “So make sure you correctly configure them and manage them. Even if they are smaller, they can create big problems. Do not rely on a single point of failure, because as we saw (an attacker could ) change server configuration and change in value of temperature.”
“When it comes to embedded devices, security is not always there, so go with those vendors that provide security features because these devices need security as well,”Balduzzi said.

