With the accelerating pace of technological innovation and the increasing sophistication of cyber threats, the traditional approach of developing cybersecurity defenses with the sole purpose of keeping attackers out, while still essential, is no longer sufficient.
Acknowledging the inevitability of cyberattacks, the potential for human error, and complexity of our systems makes it imperative to shift our focus toward building resilient systems, according to a new report.
Resilience entails the ability of a system to anticipate, withstand, recover from, and adapt to cyberattacks and natural or accidental disruptions. Organizations’ approach must shift from a futile quest for absolute invulnerability to a more realistic strategy of resiliency in which they can control the impacts of failures.
Do More to Protect Cyber-Physical
This report, created by the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST) describes why organizations need to do more to protect the cyber and physical interaction.
Cyber-physical systems are physical systems that rely on computing technologies for sensing, analysis, tracking, controls, connectivity, coordination, or communications. Most of the systems we depend upon across sectors, spanning our electricity, water, healthcare, communications, transportation, manufacturing, and defense, are now cyber-physical in nature.
For example, the electric grid relies on automated sensing, controls, and communication networks. This allows for real-time monitoring, predictive maintenance, effective coordination among multiple power sources and electricity- producing organizations, and efficient power distribution.
Even systems that might not appear to be cyber-physical (e.g., financial services) have extensive cyber-physical dependencies on sectors that do, or per their reliance on their own data centers, which are inherently cyber-physical. Given their vital nature, the effective operation of cyber-physical systems is paramount and the core functioning of systems must continue despite failures of one or more computational or physical components.
Cyber-physical resilience is the capacity of an integrated system to keep running – even if not at peak performance – should it lose specific functions. Challenges include degradation or cessation of one or more aspects of the computational or physical functions due to component failures, human errors, natural disasters, or malicious attacks. For instance, if one or more of computer-based controls, sensors, or Internet communications employed in a water treatment plant fail, the system should still ensuring clean water is still delivered to homes. We should have an understanding in advance of how and how well such operations will proceed in light of one or more failures.
Improve Ability to Address Challenges
The report conveys PCAST’s endorsement for initiatives underway in the public and private sectors.
The goal of the recommendations is to radically improve the ability to address the challenges facing government and all of our critical infrastructure, which is typically in private hands. Public and private sector organizations could use this report as a foundation to broaden and intensify their resilience initiatives.
The following are a list of recommendations from PCAST:
Establish Performance Goals: Set minimum viable delivery objectives for critical services, even in the face of adversity, and establish more ambitious performance goals to measure every organization’s ability to achieve and sustain those.
Bolster and Coordinate Research and Development: Put in place a more coordinated national R&D agenda, including delivering a National Critical Infrastructure Observatory to outmatch adversaries in knowing and resolving our weaknesses and concentrations of risk.
Break Down Silos and Strengthen Government Cyber-Physical Resilience Capacity: Clarify the what and why of the national critical functions list to help each sector prioritize. Enhance the staffing and capabilities of sector risk management agencies so they can perform their critical role in increasing resilience across their sector in close partnership with Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) as the designated national coordinator for critical infrastructure and resilience.
Develop Greater Industry, Board, Chief Executive, and Executive Accountability: Increase the expectation that boards, chief executives, and other executives, as the owners and operators of our critical infrastructure, will lead from the front. More of the private sector should augment their “tone at the top” with “resources in the ranks” to be prepared for adverse events. This will require greater engagement with and from the most senior members of private sector organizations.
Click here for more on the Strategy for Cyber-Physical Resilience.

