To that end, on Wednesday, October 28, the Eighth Circuit upheld an Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) citation against Evansville, Wyoming-based Hall Trucking, Inc. after one of its trucks fatally struck an employee during an oil rig move on November 2, 2022, at an oil drilling site near Epping, North Dakota.
The case initially ended up reviewed by an administrative law judge, who affirmed the citation, leading Hall Trucking to appeal the decision to the Eighth Circuit.
OSHA issued a single violation of the General Duty Clause and proposed a penalty of $10,938 against Hall Trucking.
Originally, OSHA cited Hall Trucking under the general duty clause requiring employers to keep workplaces free from known hazards likely to cause death or serious harm. Part of that fix would be to include an internal traffic control plan (ITCP) which can include steps to keep workers and trucks apart, high-visibility gear requirements, and targeted training.
Hall Trucking argued its existing safety procedures were adequate. Those procedures included back-up alarms, cameras, training, high-visibility gear, and a policy of firing anyone who broke the rules.
Procedures in Reality
That is what was on paper, but during the fatal incident, the back-up camera had glare. The spotter had his back turned. Employees were not wearing high-visibility gear. Additionally, workers routinely ignored back-up alarms.
Moreover, the company had never given employees written policies for struck-by hazards.
The court noted putting safety measures in a manual is not enough “unless those measures are actually followed and enforced.”
The company also argued ITCPs were too vague and too rigid for field conditions that could change 50 to 100 times a day.
The record showed ITCPs are flexible, account for site-specific conditions, and do not need continuous revision.
The court’s ruling has significant implications for Hall Trucking and the trucking industry as a whole. It reinforces the importance of adhering to safety regulations and the necessity of implementing effective safety measures in high-risk environments. Employers in similar industries may need to reevaluate their safety protocols to ensure compliance with OSHA standards and to protect their employees from potential hazards.
For safety teams the lesson learned in this case is if a company has a safety policy and nobody follows it, it is not a safety policy.
Click here to read the court’s decision.

