Just over 20 years ago, two massive explosions occurred just seconds apart destroyed the Mustang, Nevada, Sierra Chemical Company Kean Canyon explosives manufacturing plant, killing four workers and injuring six others.
The Chemical Safety Board (CSB) found the absence of participation in process safety activities at Sierra Chemical Company was a major cause of the January 7, 1998 explosions, as it led to workers lacking sufficient understanding of the process hazards and controls.
In one case, the worker participation program at the plant made no provision for employees to be involved in the development of safety programs and policies.
Workers at the site did not use and were not aware of written operating procedures and safety information relevant to their work activity.
Neither were workers aware of any specific hazards associated with the materials at the facility, aside from the fact the materials were explosives and they were required to wear dust masks. According to the workers the CSB investigators interviewed, no operators helped develop any of the safety programs. Workers were not even aware a worker participation program existed. Worker safety activities were generally limited to preventing fires and wearing personal protective equipment. While workers were told to report problems, the issues they raised were not acted upon, as the supervisor considered them to be production issues, even though they presented safety hazard implications.
While it would be easy to say that happened over 20 years ago and the lack of workers not being involved would not occur today, that is simply not the case.
Worker Participation Digest
That is one reason why the CSB released a safety digest on the value of worker participation to prevent chemical incidents.
The digest shows how the lack of worker participation was a factor in several major incidents investigated by the CSB because workers and their representatives were not engaged to help identify hazards and reduce risks.
“Worker engagement is key to an effective process safety program,” said CSB Board Member Rick Engler. “After all, it’s employees who are so often in direct contact with the hazards – and have the experience and knowledge to help prevent them.”
The digest discusses four incidents that led to 13 employee deaths, many injuries, and, in one case, 15,000 residents living near the facility seeking medical evaluation.
The incidents took place at an explosives manufacturing site, a chemical production facility, and two oil refineries. They occurred in Nevada, Washington, California, and Louisiana. Each of these CSB investigations found worker participation programs were inadequate, despite the existence of federal regulations and industry standards.
Recommendations
As a result of its investigative findings over the years, CSB issued recommendations to employers (both companies and specific facilities), unions, industry groups, state governments, and federal agencies aimed at improving worker participation in the following ways:
• Creating or improving opportunities for workers to participate directly in matters involving process safety management and major incidents prevention
• Empowering workers to provide input on how work is performed, whether through safety-related committees, special projects, inspections and audits, hazard analyses, and other specific measures (such as designing new operating procedures or assessing and improving process safety culture)
• Sharing safety information or communicating safety improvements as a part of strengthening a company’s or facility’s overall safety management system
• Enabling workers to bring safety issues to the attention of management without fear of retaliation or reprisal
• Collecting data (e.g., incident tracking, indicator data, and metrics) to help ensure critical information is retained and used to continuously improve safety
• Worker training opportunities and information sharing regarding the nature of the hazards present in the workplace, lessons learned from other sites, the outcome of incident investigations, and exposure to both established industry best practices and the results of safety-related research relevant to a company’s or facility’s operations
• Strengthening worker participation requirements in industry standards and state and federal regulations

