In order to provide guidance to critical infrastructure providers, a set of cross-sector Cybersecurity Performance Goals (CPGs) released Thursday from the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA).

The CPGs provide voluntary guidance to critical infrastructure partners to help them prioritize security investments toward areas that will have the greatest impact on their cybersecurity. These goals should end up implemented in concert with the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Cybersecurity Framework (CSF).

CISA developed the CPGs based on extensive feedback from partners with the goal of creating a final product that reflects input from a wide range of groups including federal agencies, the private sector, and international partners. We achieved this goal via written comments, workshops, listening sessions, and focused discussions with experts across a variety of disciplines.

The CPGs should be:

  • A baseline set of cybersecurity practices broadly applicable across critical infrastructure with known risk-reduction value.
  • A benchmark for critical infrastructure operators to measure and improve their cybersecurity maturity.
  • A combination of recommended practices for IT and OT owners, including a prioritized set of security practices.
  • Unique from other control frameworks as they consider not only the practices that address risk to individual entities, but also the aggregate risk to the nation. 

The CPGs prescribe an abridged subset of actions – a “QuickStart guide” – for the NIST CSF to help organizations prioritize their investments. Along with the CPGs themselves, CISA is releasing an accompanying Checklist that prioritizes each goal by cost, impact, and complexity.

Schneider Bold

Among the general list of CPGs, CISA lists:

  1. Account security
  2. Device security
  3. Data security
  4. Governance and training
  5. Vulnerability management
  6. Supply chain/third party
  7. Response and recovery
  8. Other
    — Network segmentation
    — Detecting relevant threats and TTPs
    — Email security

Feds Listened
Industry security professionals generally had a positive outlook about what CISA had to offer.

“CISA took extensive input and feedback from industry stakeholders and this updated guidance reflects that they were listening closely, providing actionable but not overly prescriptive guidance – exactly the type of support the community has been requesting,” said Robert M. Lee, chief executive and co-founder of Dragos. “It allows asset owners and operators to work toward shared goals while giving them the flexibility and expertise to implement them in ways best suited to their organizations and risks. Most of the CPGs map closely to the critical controls needed for strong OT cybersecurity – namely, having an incident response plan, a defensible architecture, visibility and monitoring, secure remote access, and key vulnerability management. This guidance can help lift industrial cybersecurity standards across the board to better protect our nation’s critical infrastructure. CISA’s continued focus on OT cybersecurity as foundational to national security, and distinct from IT cybersecurity, is an important contribution to the community’s advancement.”

“The updated cross-sector performance goals released are general provisions for critical infrastructure covering both IT (enterprise) and OT (industrial control systems) environments,” said Ron Fabela, chief technology officer and co-founder at SynSaber. “These CPGs are tied directly to NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) controls, which are considered a subset of the overall CSF. The CPGs are also entirely voluntary as stated in the report, to be used as a guide for all organizations to improve their cybersecurity posture.

“This does not come without some challenges specific to OT systems. Top down guidance from CISA or other agencies are often hard to apply and measure across such large and diverse critical infrastructure sectors. Difficult to measure criteria for success are left to those doing the measurement. There’s also the tension between performance based goals that are not overly prescriptive (as they should be) and guidance that is non-applicable to the audience. Even within this report and checklist asset owners are left analyzing what is applicable and feasible. Many of the goals have unique callouts for “OT” and plenty of caveats such as “where technically feasible,” a phrase that has been the bane of effective cybersecurity governance of ICS.

“Overall, asset owners need not fret over renewed guidance from CISA. The goals in the CPG report should not come as a surprise to anyone operating cybersecurity programs. ICS applicability and action have always been a challenge when it comes to top down policy, but asset owners, SOC managers, CISOs and technicians should see the CISA CPGs as an opportunity to implement real security projects within their organization even if the CPGs lack regulatory teeth.”

Some Ambiguity
“Overall I think the document is useful in that it is making the NIST CSF (and other similar frameworks) more digestible and actionable/user friendly, and providing more well-defined guidance on specific actions to take to reduce risk across the enterprise (on both the IT/OT side),” said Derek McCarthy, director of field engineering at NetRise. “With that said, there are still areas that are left fairly ambiguous – one very important example under the “Supply Chain / Third Party” section is in: 6.1 – Reduce risk by buying more secure products and services from more secure suppliers, where the recommended action reads: ‘Organizations’ procurement documents include cybersecurity requirements and questions, which are evaluated in vendor selection such that, given two offerings of roughly similar cost and function, the more secure offering and/or supplier is preferred.’

“What is the criteria for ‘more secure offering/supplier?’ Something that we talk about a lot is if you are doing research on two different vendors – you probably will look up the vendors/devices in the National Vulnerability Database (NVD) … very often you will find that one vendor may have dozens, or even hundreds of known vulnerabilities published for a specific product or product line. Another vendor may have zero vulnerabilities published for a specific device, or in many cases none of their devices have any known vulnerabilities published in the NVD. At the surface level, it may seem that the vendor with less vulnerabilities is more secure. Somewhat counter-intuitively, we often find that the exact opposite is true. The vendor or product with more published vulnerabilities is often indicative that there is a more mature product security incident response team (PSIRT), which will undoubtedly lead to more secure devices, both upon purchase as well as through the lifecycle of the device. This is especially true when looking at vendors that have no published vulnerabilities – no one on Earth makes perfectly secure software, and this is almost always indicative of a vendor that lacks fundamental product security capabilities.”

“My first reaction is that CISA is saying all the right things,” said Padraic O’Reilly, DoD cyber risk advisor and co-founder of CyberSaint. “(CISA Director Jen) Easterly stresses that small to mid-sized organizations are struggling with cyber risk management. I see this every day in my work as the founder of a risk management software concern. Many want to improve but do not know where to start or where to direct resources. The stated purpose of the CPG … to help identify and prioritize the most important cybersecurity practices along with support in making a compelling argument to ensure adequate resources for driving down risk … is the central problem in cyber at this moment in time.

Targeted Approach
“Additionally, CISA is right, while the Cybersecurity Framework has made great progress toward standardizing the approach to risk management across the CI sectors, many companies have been left behind. One can think of this publication as offering a more targeted approach to risk reduction through an optimal set of practices that should align to the CSF, at least in theory.

“The goal of all cyber risk management should be the discovery of an optimal set of remediations that can then be resourced and tracked. This is a large part of what our customers do in our software, but lower maturity customers struggle with the complexity of this task. CISA has access to the most extensive threat data, as well, which is absolutely necessary to find the top areas for immediate remediation. They have also tied their guidance to MITRE and the TTPs, which is best practice and an approach we use, as well.”

Click here to view the Cybersecurity Performance Goals document.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This