When it comes to poultry processing worker safety, current risk mitigation efforts are insufficient, a new report found.

Dangers associated with poultry process are legendary to the point where the feds wanted to learn how they can make the industry safer for workers.

In November of 2022, the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) funded a research team from the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF) to “assist the FSIS in assessing the relationship between evisceration line speed in young chicken and swine slaughter establishments and the scope, magnitude, and factors that influence worker safety and health risks for establishment employees impacted by the speed of the slaughter line.”

The scope of work included evaluating the impact of evisceration line speed on the risk of acute and chronic work-related musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs) and antimicrobial-related respiratory exposure.

Between November 2023 and April 2024, the Poultry Processing Line Speed Evaluation (PULSE) study team enrolled 1,047 poultry processing establishment workers at eleven New Poultry Inspection System (NPIS) establishments operating at evisceration line speeds between 140 and 175 birds per minute (BPM).

Schneider Bold

The study team conducted surveys and medical interviews and took measurements of ergonomic exposures and airborne peracetic acid (PAA) concentrations. Data from the surveys, interviews, and exposure measures ended up analyzed.

High Risk for MSDs

In one component of the survey, 81 percent of evaluated workers were at high risk for musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs).

The highest mean Peak Force Index Threshold Limit Value (PFI-TLV) scores were among workers performing breast processing, shoulder processing, and trim/rework jobs.

PFI-TLV scores for many of the evaluated poultry processing jobs were similar in magnitude to the PFI-TLV scores of jobs in industries such as large appliance manufacturing, crop harvesting, and furniture assembly. Prior prospective epidemiological studies found elevated rates of carpal tunnel syndrome and other upper extremity musculoskeletal disorders among workers in such industries.

Piece rate, like the number of chicken parts handled per minute by a worker, ended up associated with MSD risk (PFI-TLV score).

Researchers conducted an analysis to examine unstratified associations between piece rate and PFI-TLV score among all workers included in the study and separate associations between piece rate and PFI-TLV score stratified by job across all establishments. In the end, piece rate had little or no association with evisceration line speed. Also, piece rate ended up determined predominantly by the job-specific line speed and staffing level.

Evisceration line speed category did not associate with the PFI-TLV score, the primary metric of upper extremity MSD risk.

Analyses examined unstratified associations between evisceration line speed category and PFI-TLV score among all workers included in the study and separate associations between evisceration line speed category and PFI-TLV score stratified by job across all establishments.

Reducing MSD Risk

For some jobs like live hang, chiller rehang and coning increased staffing levels or reduced job- specific line speed at establishments operating at higher evisceration line speeds reduced increases in MSD risk, the report said.

Meanwhile, airborne concentrations of Peracetic Acid (PAA) did not differ by evisceration line speed category.
At 5 of the 11 establishments, airborne PAA concentrations of at least one job exceeded the recommended ACGIH STEL of 0.4 ppm. In addition, airborne PAA concentrations of 13 (21 percent) of the 61 establishment-specific jobs measured exceeded the ACGIH STEL of 0.4 ppm.

In the end, poultry processing workers face a very dangerous job. While evisceration line speed did not associate with MSD risk, rather, piece rate, a metric of job-specific line speed and staffing level, ended up associated with MSD risk. The absence of an association between evisceration line speed and job-specific MSD risk was due in part to higher job-specific staffing levels, lower job-specific line speed, or both, at establishments operating at higher evisceration line speeds in comparison to those operating at lower evisceration line speeds.

Airborne PAA concentrations were greater than the ACGIH STEL among 1 in 5 jobs that were sampled, indicating that current risk mitigation efforts are insufficient.

Click here for more on the report.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This