By Gregory Hale
SolarWinds was a well-documented attack where the software monitoring provider suffered a huge supply chain attack in 2019 for which the company learned about later on the next year, but the company and its chief information security officer are now facing fraud and internal control failures charges.
The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Monday unveiled the charges against Austin, Texas-based software company SolarWinds Corporation and its chief information security officer, Timothy G. Brown, for fraud and internal control failures relating to allegedly known cybersecurity risks and vulnerabilities.
In 2019, hackers suspected to be Russian, compromised the automated build environment for the SolarWinds’ Orion monitoring software, and in the spring of 2020 the company pushed out malicious Orion updates to 18,000 SolarWinds customers.
The complaint alleges from at least its October 2018 initial public offering through at least its December 2020 announcement it was the target of a massive, nearly two-year long cyberattack, dubbed “SUNBURST,” SolarWinds and Brown defrauded investors by overstating SolarWinds’ cybersecurity practices and understating or failing to disclose known risks.
SEC Charges
In its filings with the SEC during this period, SolarWinds is charged with misleading investors by disclosing only generic and hypothetical risks at a time when the company and Brown knew of specific deficiencies in SolarWinds’ cybersecurity practices as well as the increasingly elevated risks the company faced at the same time.
As the complaint alleges, SolarWinds’ public statements about its cybersecurity practices and risks were at odds with its internal assessments, including a 2018 presentation prepared by a company engineer and shared internally, including with Brown, SolarWinds’ remote access set-up was “not very secure” and that someone exploiting the vulnerability “can basically do whatever without us detecting it until it’s too late,” which could lead to “major reputation and financial loss” for SolarWinds.
Similarly, as alleged in the SEC’s complaint, 2018 and 2019 presentations by Brown stated, respectively, the “current state of security leaves us in a very vulnerable state for our critical assets” and that “[a]ccess and privilege to critical systems/data is inappropriate.”
In addition, the SEC’s complaint alleges multiple communications among SolarWinds employees, including Brown, throughout 2019 and 2020 questioned the company’s ability to protect its critical assets from cyberattacks.
‘Backends Not Resilient’
For example, according to the SEC’s complaint, in June 2020, while investigating a cyberattack on a SolarWinds customer, Brown wrote it was “very concerning” that the attacker may have been looking to use SolarWinds’ Orion software in larger attacks because “our backends are not that resilient;” and a September 2020 internal document shared with Brown and others stated, “the volume of security issues being identified over the last month have [sic] outstripped the capacity of Engineering teams to resolve.”
The SEC’s complaint claims Brown was aware of SolarWinds’ cybersecurity risks and vulnerabilities but failed to resolve the issues or, at times, sufficiently raise them further within the company. As a result of these lapses, the company allegedly also could not provide reasonable assurances its most valuable assets, including its flagship Orion product, had adequate protection.
SolarWinds made an incomplete disclosure about the SUNBURST attack in a December 14, 2020, Form 8-K filing, following which its stock price dropped approximately 25 percent over the next two days and approximately 35 percent by the end of the month.
“We allege that, for years, SolarWinds and Brown ignored repeated red flags about SolarWinds’ cyber risks, which were well known throughout the company and led one of Brown’s subordinates to conclude: ‘We’re so far from being a security minded company,’” said Gurbir S. Grewal, director of the SEC’s Division of Enforcement. “Rather than address these vulnerabilities, SolarWinds and Brown engaged in a campaign to paint a false picture of the company’s cyber controls environment, thereby depriving investors of accurate material information. Today’s enforcement action not only charges SolarWinds and Brown for misleading the investing public and failing to protect the company’s ‘crown jewel’ assets, but also underscores our message to issuers: Implement strong controls calibrated to your risk environments and level with investors about known concerns.”
SolarWinds Responds
SolarWinds President and Chief Executive, Sudhakar Ramakrishna, said Monday he remained shocked at the SEC action.
“When I joined SolarWinds just days after the company learned of SUNBURST, my immediate focus was supporting our customers as we quickly contained, remediated, and eradicated the issue – while helping our customers ensure their environments were secure,” Ramakrishna said in a blog post. “We shared information about the incident as it was confirmed. The transparency of our response and our ongoing commitment to public-private partnerships has been widely praised in the global IT and security communities. We defined and implemented our Secure by Design initiative and have been commended broadly for advancing cybersecurity.
“How we responded to SUNBURST is exactly what the U.S. government seeks to encourage. So, it is alarming that the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has now filed what we believe is a misguided and improper enforcement action against us, representing a regressive set of views and actions inconsistent with the progress the industry needs to make and the government encourages.
“The truth of the matter is that SolarWinds maintained appropriate cybersecurity controls prior to SUNBURST and has led the way ever since in continuously improving enterprise software security based on evolving industry standards and increasingly advanced cybersecurity threats. For these reasons, we will vigorously oppose this action by the SEC,” Ramakrishna said.
SEC Complaint
The SEC’s complaint, filed in the Southern District of New York, alleges SolarWinds and Brown violated the antifraud provisions of the Securities Act of 1933 and of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934; SolarWinds violated reporting and internal controls provisions of the Exchange Act; and Brown aided and abetted the company’s violations. The complaint seeks permanent injunctive relief, disgorgement with prejudgment interest, civil penalties, and an officer and director bar against Brown.
“The SEC’s charges now risk the open information-sharing across the industry that cybersecurity experts agree is needed for our collective security,” Ramakrishna said. “They also risk disenfranchising earnest cybersecurity professionals across the country, taking these cyber warriors off the front lines. I worry these actions will stunt the growth of public-private partnerships and broader information-sharing, making us all even more vulnerable to security attacks.”
In January 2021, shareholders filed a class action suit saying while the company did a fine job of dealing with and fixing the aftermath of the attack, the impact of the breach and the disclosure had a serious effect on the share price.
To that end, the company in 2022 agreed to pay $26 million to settle a class action lawsuit from shareholders, the company said in a SEC filing.
In the SEC filing last year the SEC said:
“On October 28, 2022, SolarWinds entered into a binding settlement term sheet with respect to the previously disclosed consolidated putative class action lawsuit. The settlement, if approved, would require the Company to pay $26 million to fund claims submitted by class members, the legal fees of plaintiffs’ counsel and the costs of administering the settlement. The proposed settlement resolves all claims asserted against the Company and the other named defendants in connection with the class action litigation and would contain provisions that the settlement does not constitute an admission, concession, or finding of any fault, liability, or wrongdoing of any kind by the Company or any defendant. There can be no assurance that the final settlement agreement will be executed or that such agreement will be approved by the court.”
SEC Investigation Notice
The filing went on to say the SEC is investigating the incident.
“Also on October 28, 2022, the enforcement staff of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) provided the Company with a “Wells Notice” relating to its investigation into the previously disclosed cyberattack on the Company’s Orion Software Platform and internal systems. The Wells Notice states that the SEC staff has made a preliminary determination to recommend that the SEC file an enforcement action against the Company alleging violations of certain provisions of the U.S. federal securities laws with respect to its cybersecurity disclosures and public statements, as well as its internal controls and disclosure controls and procedures.”

