This understanding comes after multiple international cybersecurity agencies issued multiple alerts about malicious Russian cyber operations and potential attacks on critical infrastructure, the discovery of two new OT-specific pieces of malware, Industroyer2 and InController/PipeDream, and the disclosure of all types of OT vulnerabilities.
With that understanding, IBM Security X-Force analysts looked at X-Force Incident Response (IR) and Managed Security Services (MSS) data to provide OT defenders with the intelligence necessary to protect their assets.
Most Common Attack Attempts: Widespread and likely indiscriminate internal and external vulnerability scanning, as well as brute force attacks and use of weak and outdated encryption standards, are the most common attack attempts against OT-related industries’ IT and OT environments observed so far in 2022.
Phishing Top Attack
Most Common Initial Access Vector: Phishing continued to be the most prevalent initial access vector identified across incidents that IBM responded to across OT industries.
Top Incidents: The majority of incidents X-Force responded to involved malspam, with clients receiving emails with the Emotet Trojan and being hijacked to forward it, and to a lesser extent remote access trojans (RATs), ransomware, and business email compromise (BEC) attacks.
Manufacturing was the most-attacked industry in 2021, according to the 2021 X-Force Threat Intelligence Index. So far in 2022, manufacturing remains in the lead across both metrics at 23 percent of total IR cases and 65 percent among OT-related industries.
This is just ahead of where manufacturing stood throughout 2021, victimized in 61 percent of incidents in OT-related industries to which X-Force responded, according to the index. Of the other OT-heavy industries so far in 2022, electric utilities place a distant second at 13 percent and oil and gas and transportation tied for third at 8 percent, all three of which are similar to their proportion of attacks through 2021. Heavy and civil engineering accounts for about 3 percent and mining just shy of 2 percent.
Looking at identified initial infection vectors, phishing served as the initial infection vector in 78 percent of incidents X-Force responded to across these industries so far in 2022. This tracks with phishing’s position as the lead infection vector across all incidents in 2021. This also highlights the importance of layered phishing defenses, including regular user education and training, software solutions to filter malicious email, email sandboxing solutions to analyze any attachments or linked payloads, web proxies to analyze linked domains and attachment downloads, and application allow listing and Attack Surface Reduction rules to limit which extensions and payloads can be executed by end users.
EDR, XDR Can Help
Solutions such as Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) and Extended Detection and Response (XDR) can help detect post-compromise actions on endpoints if Command and Control is established. This should also be combined with strong network and user behavior analytic detections and defenses in the event phishing is successful.
Scanning and exploitation of vulnerabilities on external attack surfaces made up 11 percent of initial infection vectors in incidents. Proactively identifying and managing the external attack surface of IT and OT networks is essential to understanding what ports, services, and applications may be exposed to attackers externally and may require further hardening, patching, or isolation.
Once the external attack surface is identified, focused vulnerability management can help address IT vulnerabilities, though such patching is notoriously difficult in OT environments where downtime is difficult to schedule and system refresh timelines can stretch over many years. Because of this, one might expect successful compromise through vulnerability exploitation to be observed more frequently, but typically OT equipment itself is not exposed directly to the Internet and is typically targeted via IT network access, according to the index.
Proper network security isolation is key to reducing attack paths for threat actors seeking to pivot from IT to OT networks. The use of removable media tied for second at 11 percent of incidents, underscoring the long-standing threat that such media poses to OT networks, often by end users using infected USB media drives between operator workstations and personal laptops while in the field.
Steps to Boost Security
Proper segmentation, proactive testing of security controls, knowing your environment, and hardening systems are just a few of the steps available to secure these assets.
As for removable media, ideally, USB flash drives should be prohibited when possible. If absolutely necessary, strictly control the number of portable devices approved for use in your environment and disable autorun features for any removable media.
- IBM X-Force made a series of recommendations to achieve a greater security presence, including:
- Implement layered phishing defenses.
- Proactively identify and manage the external attack surface of IT and OT networks to understand what ports, services, and applications may be exposed to attackers externally and may require further hardening, patching, or isolation.
- Segment your IT and OT networks properly and proactively test security controls
- Ideally, USB flash drives should be prohibited when possible. If absolutely necessary, designate a single device for any maintenance, re-format it for every use, and disable autorun features for any removable media.
- Refine and mature your vulnerability management program to help protect your assets. This should include dedicating a well-resourced and supported team to the task and prioritizing CVEs for OT networks when appropriate.
- Know the types of encryption deployed in your environments and weigh the security risks with the possible benefits of continuing use of older encryption methods based on the sensitivity of the communications being secured.
- Change weak or default passwords found on devices, ensure multi-factor authentication is deployed and regular re-authentication is required for as many logins as technically feasible, keep applications and operating systems updated, and implement lockout policies.
Click here for more on the report.

