By Gregory Hale
The cloud is coming, and it is increasingly controlling safety critical processes. If safety is critical, if reliability is critical, there must be manual operations to fall back and that is where cyber-informed engineering is relevant to cloud-based designs.
“For most of us, the clouds we’re talking about is with the people who live at our vendors, the people who built the drilling machines, the people who built the turbines, the people who built the pumps,” said Andrew Ginter, vice president of industrial security at Waterfall Security Solutions during his talk entitled “Future Perfect: CIE for Safety-Critical Clouds” at the inaugural 2025 Level Zero Conference in Atlanta, Georgia. “The killer app for 30 years, sending data into the vendors, has been predictive maintenance. To me the typical cloud app is a bunch of computers, a standard system in the vendor’s office giving us advice.”
The industrial Internet is the future of automation, and cloud systems are integral to unlocking enormous benefits, but with that said, there are also huge risks. Cyber-informed engineering enables end users to reap almost all the benefits while suffering almost none of the risk.
Ginter lined up a couple of scenarios.
Tractors Turned Off
Out in the Ukraine war, the battle line between the invaders and the defenders often moved back and forth. When the battle line moved toward Russia, the Ukrainian farmers took million-dollar John Deere tractors, went into the field of battle, and pulled out abandoned Russian equipment like tanks.
Some of the tanks they gave to the Ukrainian military because the tanks ended up abandoned in the heat of battle and were still usable. Some of them were scrap. This annoyed the Russians, Ginter said.
“When the battle line moved back toward the Ukraine, at one point, it moved through a small town that had a John Deere dealership,” Ginter said. “The Russian soldiers went into the dealership and took $3 million worth of equipment and drove it 700 kilometers into Russia.
“This annoyed John Deere because it was their dealership, and it just lost $2 million worth of equipment, so they turned it all off. It’s dead now,” he said.
John Deere was able to use their system to make the stolen equipment unusable.
While that was a nice war tactic, in the end think about what happened.
What if John Deere gets it into their head to turn off all the tractors in Europe during planting season? How about if the Russians hacked into the John Deere cloud and turn off all the tractors in Europe at planting season?
“What kind of Pandora’s box did we just open?” Ginter said. “This is the world we live in. People are connecting through the Internet into, typically, vendors, but it could be any cloud. There’s a risk in these Internet services ending up colonized.”
Hacked Encryption
“We have a cloud service usually at an industrial vendor. We’ve got the Internet. We have sensors connected to the physical process, vibration sensors, any kind of industrial sensors,” Ginter said. “The sensors may be sending information with a TCP connection, encrypted all the way through several levels of firewalls out to the cloud.
“What are the risks here? Well, the risk is cyber sabotage; sabotage on physical operations. The risk is that all of these deployments are software. I worked with software for 20 years, despite my best efforts and the best efforts of all of my colleagues and every organization I was ever part of every piece of production quality software had a defect in it. Some of those defects were security holes. Some of those holes we knew about and we’re desperately trying to fix, and some of them we did not know about, but our enemies did. This is what we did in our software, and it can be hacked,” he said.
For safety critical applications, firewalls are not enough. Like in the John Deere case, we are looking at a classic pivot. Taking over a cloud system and using the cloud system to compromise edge devices inside of sites.
“What we’re doing is we’re sending the attacks from the cloud into sites inside encrypted communications,” Ginter said. “We might believe that encryption is a security mechanism. It saves us. What does it save us from? It saves us from attacks from the Internet, man-in-the- middle attacks. If the endpoint ends up compromised, it has legitimate access to the encryption keys and can send an attack inside the encrypted connection.”
Worst Case Unacceptable
At a small shoe factory, that may be okay. That company can buy insurance. Maybe in some cases the consequence of compromise is acceptable, but often the worst case is not acceptable, he said.
Ginter added another scenario.
“Let’s say that we have a temperature sensitive process,” Ginter said. “We have a random, unpredictable set of inputs coming into a temperature-sensitive process, and each input has to be processed at the right temperature, or we have a safety incident.
“What we have in a cloud is an AI that gets a constant fee of what inputs are coming into the process and figures out the optimal sequencing of those inputs because the temperature sensitive process has a ratio. It takes time to run. And once it’s at temperature, it takes time to cool off. If we have a lot of inputs coming in and we need a lower temperature, we’d like to cool it off and not waste the energy and process those inputs at a lower temperature.
“And then if we see inputs that require a higher temperature, we would like to heat things up so that every input is processed at the correct temperature. Figuring that out, reordering the inputs for optimal processing is a difficult problem. It’s one that we might want an AI to help us with or an expert system.
“But if that system sends the wrong instruction, if that system ends up compromised and sends you wrong instruction, if we’re in a process, we’re done for. The inputs are processed at the wrong temperature, and there’s a risk to people at the site and into the neighboring communities,” Ginter said.
What do we do?
Going Old School
So, one idea is, for the safety critical part, throwing a safety instrumented system or an air gap. Essentially going old-school.
“The system does its job,” Ginter said. “Asking the question, is this input being processed at a safe temperature? Is a much simpler question than the question, what is the optimal sequence for inputs to maximize energy efficiency in a safe way?”
“Let the cloud do the hard work, send information into our control system, and have a backstop,” Ginter said. “Now, the safety system can check and say, ‘Am I still safe?’ Much simpler process. You can with old-school air gap safety systems. What is your worst-case residual risk? The bad guys could pin it through their connections into the sensors. They could make a mess of our industrial network. We might go down. Down time is a residual risk. But we’ve taken safety off the table.”
Here’s another design. Water systems.
The control system has moved entirely in the cloud. The operator is remote, logged into a cloud system, and is operating, typically, dozens of small water systems simultaneously to their HMI. What’s the risk?
The risk is that the bad guys will get into the cloud, pivot through the cloud, into the software in the control system. I either produce water that’s not safe to drink or treat wastewater incorrectly and release it in the environment, or in the worst case, there can be safety threats in wastewater treatment.
Manual Fallback
In the end, sites generally have a manual fallback. They know even with multiple redundant Internet connections, there’s going to be a day when they lose connection, and they cannot afford to be without water, Ginter said. And so, they have manual fallbacks in an emergency. They call everybody in for 12-hour days. They come in off vacation, and then operate the water system manually until the Internet comes back, until the cloud has been uncompromised by restoring the virtual machines, and we’re back. That is a legitimate design.
These are all cyber-informed engineering principles.
“If safety is critical; if reliability is critical, have a manual operations fall back,” Ginter said. “Cyber-informed engineering is relevant to these cloud-based designs. It’s the right way to look at these designs.”

