Chronic scraping and rubbing by an auxiliary line created enough damage to the main line idler sheave carrier side plate, pin boos, rope guard, and auxiliary line that it caused the guard of the main load line idler sheave carrier to fail on an offshore platform off the coast of Louisiana.

The rope guard fell approximately 100 feet, landing near personnel working below, according to an investigation by the Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement (BSEE).

On June 24, Renaissance Offshore, LLC documented an incident that occurred at Vermilion Block 369 (VR-369) platform A during completion operations, according to the BSEE accident report. The incident occurred at 12:30 p.m. when the crane wire rope guard assembly for the main load line idler sheave carrier fell striking the deck. Renaissance contracted Cased Hole Well Services (CHWS) to operate a hydraulic workover unit on location and Fluid Crane and Construction (FC) to operate the American Aero OM 450 platform crane.

On June 24, at 6:00 a.m., the Person in Charge (PIC) held the daily safety meeting to review the job task and potential hazards, according to the BSEE accident report. At 6:20 a.m. the FC operator completed the platform crane pre-use inspection form, and crane operations then began.

Loud Bang
At 12:30 p.m. a CHWS contractor started removing a sling from the crane auxiliary load line hook and heard a loud bang on the deck within 4 feet from where he was standing. He picked up the pieces of metal and brought them to his supervisor, according to the BSEE accident report. The PIC had the crane operator move the crane boom over the heliport to inspect the boom tip. The PIC discovered the wire rope guard assembly for the main load line idler sheave carrier was missing. The PIC placed the main load line out of service.

Schneider Bold

Renaissance flew a Gulf Crane (GC) mechanic to VR-369 to inspect the crane and the missing rope guard, the mechanic replaced the rope guard and placed the main load line back in service, according to the BSEE accident report. The mechanic found the auxiliary load line with high stranding damage from abrading on the rope guard and placed the auxiliary load line out of service. On June 26, the GC mechanic installed a new auxiliary load line.

On July 21, BSEE investigators (investigators) arrived at VR-369. During the initial questioning, the PIC explained to the investigator the auxiliary load line jumped over the main load line idler sheave carrier plate and came to rest on the wire rope guard, according to the BSEE accident report. The auxiliary load line abraded through the rope guard. The wire rope guard assembly is a 1/2” X 3-3/4” hex head bolt and nut with a 1-7/8” pipe spacer and two washers. The total assembly weight is approximately 1/2 pound. The wire rope guard assembly and damaged auxiliary load line were discarded and not on location for investigators to document. The total length of high stranding damage to the auxiliary load line is 130’. At the time of the incident, the crane boom was at a 63-degree angle. At a 63-degree angle, the main load line idler sheave carrier is 103’ above the platform deck. It is therefore estimated the pieces of the wire rope guard assembly fell 103’ to the platform deck.

Inside abraded main line carrier sheave side plate that is missing rope guard.
Source: BSEE


On July 27, 2investigators conducted an on-site incident follow-up. During the incident follow-up, investigators collected additional documents and requested all unavailable documents associated with the incident, according to the BSEE accident report. Investigators discovered the auxiliary load line was abrading the side plate and pin boss of the main load line idler sheave carrier. While at the platform a GC mechanic arrived. When investigators questioned him about the auxiliary load line abrading various spots on the main load line idler sheave carrier, he confirmed he observed the same issue on June 24. He attempted to mitigate the wearing and painted the sheave to monitor for further wear. The PIC decided to place the auxiliary load line out of service for further investigation.

Engineering Report
Renaissance requested a GC engineer to inspect the damage on the Idler sheave and make recommendations, according to the BSEE accident report. On August 8, GC submitted an engineering report of findings to Renaissance. GC recommended the main load line idler sheave carrier be replaced with a double-sheave idler. The new double idler sheave carrier allows the main load line and the auxiliary load line to run independently and avert abrading on the new idler sheave carrier.

This incident involved an American Aero OM 450 crane. To that end, other cranes with a similar configuration could see the same issue. Additional information is included in the BSEE Accident Investigation Report.

A list of probable causes includes:
Flawed equipment design: The auxiliary load line and boom line run in close proximity to the main load line idler sheave carrier. The auxiliary load line came in contact with the main load line idler sheave carrier when running at a high rate of speed. The auxiliary load line abraded the main load line idler sheave carrier in various locations (pin boss, side plates, and wire rope guard assembly).

A contributing cause was:
Inadequate equipment inspection: For the month of June no deficiencies were noted in the pre-use form for the auxiliary load line or the main load line idler sheave carrier. The annual inspection reports for the crane from 2017 through 2022 did not mention the auxiliary load line or the boom line running in close proximity to themain load line idler sheave carrier. Furthermore, there was no mention of the auxiliary load line or the boom line abrading the main load line idler sheave carrier.

As a result of the incident, BSEE recommends operators and contractors adhere to the following procedures:

  • Inspect idler sheaves and wire ropes for wear indicative of friction and abrading when performing pre-use inspections described in API RP 2D
  • Replace single main load line idler sheave carriers with a double sheave idler
  • Review Safety Alert #426 regarding dropped object hazards

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This