Logic solvers are the brains behind every Safety Instrumented System (SIS) and having the proper one can ensure you are not underserved or are paying too much for all the bells and whistles. That is why it is time to understand key considerations, capabilities and features that should be part of selecting the proper logic solver for functional safety.

Logic solvers are a key player when it comes to process safety. In IEC 61511 Functional Safety – Safety Instrumented Systems for the Process Industry Sector, it recommends the use of a functional safety lifecycle and provides guidance on the actual implementation of SISs for the process industry. This lifecycle guidance provides details on the analysis, design, operation and even decommissioning of the safety system by the organization. That standard is great, but to apply it, one must reference its parent standard IEC 61508: Functional Safety of Electrical/Electronic/Programmable Electronic Safety-related Systems.

At the heart of the IEC 61511 standard is the SIS which can mitigate and prevent unacceptable risk by an organization. Each SIS consists of one or more Safety Instrumented Function (SIF) that bring a process or loop to a desired safe state. The basic elements of a SIF are the sensor, logic solver and final element. The sensor monitors the process and transmits that information to a logic solver where in turn that data is able to determine what the final element should do.

Risk Reduction
Each SIF provides a defined level of risk reduction represented by its Safety Integrity Level (SIL), with SIL 4 being the highest and SIL 1 being the lowest level of safety integrity. Any device used in the SIF for a specific SIL level requirement must undergo evaluation to ensure it has proven in use history or calculated safety data such as failures and rates, Safety Failure Fraction (SFF), Probability of Failure on Demand (PFDavg), and Systematic Capability (SC), all of which are typically outlined in the equipment manufacturer’s Failure Modes Effects and Diagnostic Analysis (FMEDA) report or safety certificate.

Logic solvers chosen for a SIF most often fall into one of three categories:

Schneider Bold
  1. A device ends up chosen due to proven in use history.
  2. The device comes with published failure data such as a FMEDA report from the manufacturer.
  3. The device ended up manufactured in full compliance with IEC 61508 and has third party approval, along with accompanying FMEDA report and certificate.

While proven in use is acceptable, it is difficult to find historical performance per device. Utilizing failure data from the manufacturer’s report is certainly less burdensome, but for Type B devices which include most logic solvers, this failure data does not cover the unknown systemic failures. To that end, most safety experts acquire products designed and manufactured in compliance with the IEC 61508 standard and have third-party approval.

The Logic Solver Gap
Traditionally, there have been two types of logic solvers: One is the safety programmable logic controller (PLC) for a larger point count and more complex environment and the other is the single loop logic solver for a smaller and less complex process. But there is often a wide area between simple and more complex. That is where multichannel and multiloop logic solvers come in.

In the first instance, a safety PLC has more advantages, but comes with a higher price tag. Conversely, a single loop logic solver has less capabilities, but depending on the operation, can do the job and meet safety system requirements at a much lower cost.

The multiloop Logic Solver with logic functionality and voting capability can be an ideal solution when Safety PLCs are overkill but simple single loop logic solvers fall short.
Source: Moore Industries


In making a choice, knowing your system and operation becomes key because costs between these logic solver options can be significant.

To fill that in between void, newer IEC 610508 certified multichannel and multiloop logic solvers offer advanced capabilities with smaller point counts and far less programming overhead.

Logic Solver Determining Factors
The most common determining factors in choosing which logic solver best fits a safety application are loop and point counts, communication requirements, and the complexity of logic required for safety mitigation.

When dealing with high density point and loop counts in a centralized location where there is interdependency on various points and loops, a larger more complex logic solver such as a safety PLC may be the best choice.

For scenarios where only one or a few points need monitoring in a single SIF loop, a much less expensive and complex single loop logic solver can work. One example could be a simple on/off alarm trip used for pump/valve control.

In the wide space that exists for applications that require higher density loop/point counts with more advanced logic and loop monitoring of only a few points, there is the multiloop logic solver, which can accept multiple I/O points, handle one to three loops, performs logic and math equations, and offers flexibility for voting architectures at a fraction of the cost and complexity.

When making a logic solver choice, software also comes into play. Safety PLCs and larger safety systems offer their own proprietary software, but it often comes with lofty initial price tags, annual licensing requirements or both. Alternatively, today’s marketplace includes very capable single and multiloop logic solvers with license-free and powerful programming software, including FDT (Field Device Technology) compliant interfaces.

Depending on the requirements of your safety system, single or multiloop logic solvers usually offer straightforward easy to understand programming options.

Digital Communication Capabilities
With the growing need for SIS logic solvers to communicate with a basic process control system (BPCS) and higher-level monitoring systems, the ability to communicate via open and widely supported protocols is paramount.

To that end, MODBUS is one of the preferred protocols for communication with ancillary control and monitoring systems. MODBUS is a ubiquitous and open industrial communication protocol that can run over most communication media including twisted pair wires, wireless, fiber optics, Ethernet, cellular and satellite networks.

MODBUS/TCP, MODBUS RTU support read and write commands. But, knowing logic solvers are the last line of defense, read-only solutions should be strongly considered.

Along the lines of read-only, cybersecurity comes to mind. Taking advantage of interconnecting methods and strategies by utilizing a logic solver’s ability to communicate creates solid data analysis that will boost safety and assist with any post-accident audits.

When it comes to safety, the ability to continuously monitor data from a safety transmitter via a BPCS or safety system is invaluable. In many cases, HART smart sensors or transmitters are used in SIFs. Since the logic solver is connected directly to the HART smart transmitters, it’s important the valuable HART data doesn’t stop at the logic solver. Take note to ensure your logic solver selection can read that HART signal, or at least transmit HART data over its analog outputs to a monitoring BPCS.

Environmental Considerations
There are other key performance attributes to review like ambient operating temperature, isolation protection, operating power, and noise immunity.

Ambient operating temperature range can be an important consideration when working in remote locations, such as with oil or gas wellheads. The level of channel-to-channel and three-way isolation a logic solver provides is extremely important. Another variable to consider is the amount of power available to run a process at a site. Most logic solvers see action in control rooms where power is readily available. But when the SIS is in a remote location with limited power, the logic solver may need to run off solar or battery backup systems.

The overall ruggedness and amount of Radio Frequency Interference/Electromagnetic Interference protection a logic solver can provide are also strong considerations when dealing with processes located in harsh environments. Heat and stress shorten life cycle timeframes for electrical components, which is why some logic solvers have electrical components that provide the highest level of reliability or mean time to failure. Logic solvers built with rugged aluminum casing helps dissipate heat and offers superior protection against radio frequency and electromagnetic noise.

Want to make the right logic solver choice? Understanding the safety requirements, costs, ease of programming, environmental characteristics, and digital communications capabilities will help lead to making the right logic solver decision.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This