A robot and a human are working next to each other on the production line at the automobile factory where the robot is busy rapidly assembling car doors while the human runs quality control, inspecting the doors for damage and making sure they come together as they should.

Robots and humans can make formidable teams in manufacturing, health care and numerous other industries. While the robot might be quicker and more effective at monotonous, repetitive tasks like assembling large auto parts, the person can excel at certain tasks that are more complex or require more dexterity.

But there can be a dark side to these robot-human interactions.

People are prone to making mistakes and acting unpredictably, which can create unexpected situations robots aren’t prepared to handle. When those two issues come together, the end result is not pleasant.

To that end, new research could change the way robots handle the uncertainty that comes hand-in-hand with human interactions.

Schneider Bold
Robots Making Safer Decisions

New technology is in development that can lead to processes letting robots make safer decisions around humans while still trying to complete their tasks efficiently, according to Morteza Lahijanian, an associate professor in Colorado University Boulder’s Ann and H.J. Smead Department of Aerospace Engineering Sciences.

Moreover, Lahijanian and graduate students Karan Muvvala and Qi Heng Ho devised new algorithms that help robots create the best possible outcomes from their actions in situations that carry some uncertainty and risk.

“How do we go from very structured environments where there is no human, where the robots are doing everything by themselves, to unstructured environments where there are a lot of uncertainties and other agents?” Lahijanian asked.

“If you’re a robot, you have to be able to interact with others,” Lahijanian said. “You have to put yourself out there and take a risk and see what happens. But how do you make that decision, and how much risk do you want to tolerate?”

Safer robots

Engineering professor Morteza Lahijanian, left, and graduate student Karan Muvvala, right, watch as a robotic arm completes a task using wooden blocks.
Source: Casey Cass

Similar to humans, robots have mental models they use to make decisions. When working with a human, a robot will try to predict the person’s actions and respond accordingly. The robot is optimized for completing a task – assembling an auto part, for example – but ideally, it will also take other factors into consideration.

In the new study, the research team drew upon game theory, a mathematical concept that originated in economics, to develop the new algorithms for robots. Game theory analyzes how companies, governments and individuals make decisions in a system where other “players” are also making choices that affect the ultimate outcome.

Robot Game Theory

In robotics, game theory conceptualizes a robot as being one of numerous players in a game that it’s trying to win. For a robot, “winning” is completing a task successfully – but winning is never guaranteed when there’s a human in the mix, and keeping the human safe is also a top priority.

So instead of trying to guarantee a robot will always win, the researchers proposed the concept of a robot finding an “admissible strategy.” Using such a strategy, a robot will accomplish as much of its task as possible while also minimizing any harm, including to a human.

“In choosing a strategy, you don’t want the robot to seem very adversarial,” Lahijanian said. “In order to give that softness to the robot, we look at the notion of regret. Is the robot going to regret its action in the future? And in optimizing for the best action at the moment, you try to take an action that you won’t regret.”

In the case of the auto factory, if the person makes mistakes or is not cooperative, using the researchers’ algorithms, a robot could take matters into its own hands. If the person is making mistakes, the robot will try to fix these without endangering the person. But if that doesn’t work, the robot could, for example, pick up what it’s working on and take it to a safer area to finish its task.

A robot will try to anticipate what a person will do and stay several steps ahead of them, Lahijanian said.

People’s Safety First

But the goal is not to attempt the impossible and perfectly predict a person’s actions. Instead, the goal is to create robots that put people’s safety first.

“If you want to have collaboration between a human and a robot, the robot has to adjust itself to the human. We don’t want humans to adjust themselves to the robot,” he said. “You can have a human who is a novice and doesn’t know what they’re doing, or you can have a human who is an expert. But as a robot, you don’t know which kind of human you’re going to get. So you need to have a strategy for all possible cases.”

As more industries embrace robots and artificial intelligence, there are many lingering questions about what AI will ultimately be capable of doing, whether it will be able to take over the jobs that people have historically done, and what that could mean for humanity.

But there are upsides to robots being able to take on certain types of jobs. They could work in fields with labor shortages, such as health care for older populations, and physically challenging jobs that may take a toll on workers’ health.

Lahijanian also believes, when they’re used correctly, robots and AI can enhance human talents and expand what we’re capable of doing.

“Human-robot collaboration is about combining complementary strengths: Humans contribute intelligence, judgment, and flexibility, while robots offer precision, strength, and reliability,” he said.

“Together, they can achieve more than either could alone, safely and efficiently.”

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This