By Gregory Hale
Cybersecurity relationships took a big hit this week in the aftermath of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) bringing fraud and internal control failure charges against SolarWinds and its CISO Timothy Brown.
SEC charges against Austin, Texas-based software company SolarWinds Corporation and Brown, for fraud and internal control failures related to them knowing about cybersecurity risks and vulnerabilities.
That all came to a head because in 2019, hackers suspected to be Russian, compromised the automated build environment for the SolarWinds’ Orion monitoring software, and in the spring of 2020 the company pushed out malicious Orion updates to 18,000 SolarWinds customers.
Relationships took a hit because after SolarWinds reached a $26 million settlement on October 28, 2022, in a shareholder lawsuit, the SEC did state in the document it filed an enforcement action against the company alleging violations of certain provisions of the U.S. federal securities laws with respect to its cybersecurity disclosures and public statements.
Hit to Relationship
As the federal government is attempting to bolster its bond with the private sector in terms of sharing information, that could now take a big hit.
The public-private sector relationship was never very strong to begin with, but with the latest inroads it was making with DHS and CISA, having another agency (SEC) charge SolarWinds, which was as transparent about the attack as possible, is a definite blow.
“The SEC’s actions could affect cybersecurity’s evolving public-private sector relationship,” said Dewan Chowdhury, chief executive at security provider, malcrawler. “While SolarWinds’ transparent response to the cyberattack is commendable, the government’s assertive pursuit of accountability might deter private sector entities from engaging in collaborative cybersecurity initiatives. Striking a balance between accountability and partnership is crucial to maintaining private sector engagement in national cybersecurity efforts.
“Organizations will likely intensify their efforts to showcase their commitment to cybersecurity due diligence. The need to satisfy regulators and maintain investor confidence will drive a renewed focus on robust cybersecurity strategies. You may have the other extreme, where organizations may try to hide the incident (especially national security incident involving nation-states) due to the fear of the legal ramifications they may face” Chowdhury said.
Boost for Lawyers
“I think this will hinder both future public-private sector relationships and internal communication,” said Eric Byres, chief executive at software bill of material (SBOM) provider, aDolus Technology Inc. “Instead of being transparent and quickly disclosing information, every bit of info will be heading to legal to see what risks it exposes the company to. And this will apply to both internal and external information sharing. I’m sure Tim (Brown, SolarWinds CISO) is now regretting ever making that presentation to his bosses with statements like the ‘current state of security leaves us in a very vulnerable state for our critical assets.’ His being transparent about company limitations is now being used against him.”
One of the positives to come out of the public-private sector relationship was the potential for an open discussion of the issues and what everyone could do by working together.
“This will also stifle open discussion,” Byres said. “I note that the SEC is using a presentation prepared by a company engineer and shared internally… that SolarWinds’ remote access set-up was ‘not very secure.’ I’ve seen engineers express very divergent opinions about security priorities. It is easy for one engineer to believe that a risk is a high probability event (especially if it is a pet project). The SEC is cherry picking those negative opinions and using them against company management. The message to CISOs is ‘don’t let your engineers share their opinions in powerpoints or memos.’
“This is a dark day for the cause of transparency and open discussion in cybersecurity,” Byres said.
While that relationship may be on thin ice another one between the CISO and the C-suite and Board could end up stronger.
Opportunity for CISOs
“These charges present a unique opportunity for CISOs to advocate for increased cybersecurity budgets and enhanced defense mechanisms by striking fear in their executive leadership and boards of directors,” Chowdhury said. “The SolarWinds case underscores the severe repercussions of inadequate cybersecurity, potentially garnering executive support for necessary investments. CISOs must capitalize on this moment, emphasizing the vital role of robust cybersecurity in protecting against financial and reputational damage.”
To that end, CISOs could take it as an opportunity or a horrifying reminder to make sure they always stay on top of their game.
“The Oxford definition of fraud is criminal deception intended to result in financial or personal gain,” said Andrew Ginter, vice president industrial security at Waterfall Security Solutions. “Press reports suggest the CISO stands accused of over-stating the strength of cybersecurity measures at SolarWinds, for some sort of profit or benefit. Those details are thin.
“In my limited understanding, public companies have an obligation to disclose material things accurately and if they fail in that obligation and continue to keep trading that constitutes fraud. If that is the case here, in principle, the SEC has a leg to stand on.
“The punch line is no matter the facts of the case, the message coming from the SEC seems to be if you materially misrepresent the strength of your security program, you risk criminal charges. If you are in a situation where your security program needs to be stronger to gain a business benefit, you really need to make it stronger or you could wind up in deep trouble,” Ginter said.
Choices Facing CISOs
In end, Ginter said companies have these choices:
- Pay the money to make your cybersecurity program better
- Lie about it and risk facing charges
- Tell the truth and risk losing the benefit you would have derived from having a stronger program
Beyond cybersecurity budgets and public-private relationships, the SEC’s charges have broader implications.
“Following cybersecurity incidents, board directors and C-level executives now face potential criminal and civil repercussions,” Chowdhury said. “This risk of stock value fluctuations and legal challenges emphasizes the high stakes of cybersecurity oversight. Executives must acknowledge that cybersecurity lapses can lead to extensive consequences, necessitating a comprehensive approach to cybersecurity.”


This article fails to acknowledge the bad behavior that ultimately led to this SEC action. The Officers were engaged in “scienter” attempting to conceal the truth from investors and the public about the things “done behind closed doors” that exposed others to risk.
This action, combined with the new SEC Cybersecurity regulations that go live in December will do more to improve transparency into actual cybersecurity processes within companies and put all Officers on notice – the CISO is no longer the only one at risk from bad cybersecurity policies and practices – they are all in the same boat now.
It’s time for Officers and Directors to properly man the “cyber birds nest” to detect and avoid those cyber-icebergs in the path using a “good faith” process following NIST standards;
https://energycentral.com/c/um/what-can-titanic-teach-us-about-cybersecurity-regulations