It is no secret distillation columns are critical components in various industries, but when working properly, a process, much like a baseball umpire, runs continuously without any interference. But temperature stratification can impact a distillation column’s efficiency and safety.
To keep the distillation process operating smoothly and most productive while also protecting workers, machinery, and product integrity, temperature stratification needs constant monitoring.
When it comes to safety, traditionally, temperature monitoring across various zones occurs via safety PLCs to detect and mitigate stratification. There is no doubt safety PLCs can handle the job effectively, but costs can come into play with a more complex operating environment.
While safety is always job one in any process environment, when it comes to distillation columns and temperature stratification, there is a way to remain safe and also not spend excessive money and time on a solution. That is where a multiloop logic solver comes into play.
Key logic solver attributes for distillation column monitoring:
- Multiple inputs: Temperature stratification control and/or monitoring will require reading multiple temperature signals positioned throughout the column.
- Equation/logic: Analyzing the column’s section actual, average or absolute temperature is a requirement for product quality, column operational efficiency and safety. Performing logic on multiple temperature inputs or zones is a must.
- Straight forward voting logic: For operational efficiency, quality, or safety shutdown, multi-zone alerts and/or alarming that have dependency amongst multiple sections of the column (voting schemes) are imperative.
- Simple and license free programming: No custom or licensed software to configure or maintain the logic solver for the application.
The multiloop logic solver comes into play to help identify temperature stratification when there is uneven distribution of temperature gradients along the vertical axis of the distillation column. Yes, temperature stratification is normal in distillation columns, but thermal imbalance can come from various sources, from applying heat at the column’s base, irregular fluid flow patterns, and variations in feed composition. Differences in temperature can cause a cascade of adverse effects, ranging from diminished separation efficiency and compromised product quality to heightened safety risks within the distillation process.
Multiple Zones
That is why monitoring of temperature across multiple zones within the distillation column is key to detecting and mitigating temperature stratification. Utilizing a network of strategically positioned temperature sensors enables real-time monitoring of temperature profiles along the column’s height, facilitating early detection of stratification-induced deviations.
To that end, the SLA Multiloop Logic Solver from Moore Industries can accept up to six temperature inputs and perform an absolute differential calculation between two closely mounted temperature elements in each zone. In addition, the SLA can implement up to 16 alarms based on any input, equation, or combination of inputs/ equations.
Designed to streamline safety and efficiency within safety applications, this new type of logic solver has multiloop capabilities with up to 17 onboard I/O points, and no expansion cards required.
Logic Capable
In addition, logic capability is central to any application where multiple inputs need analyzing or massaging for product quality or higher-level decision-making.
Unlike traditional safety PLCs, the SLA’s equation/expression editor allows end-users to seamlessly execute simple or complex math functions without the need for specialized programming. This not only simplifies setup and programming but also ensures the users can meet safety requirements without heavy programming. With the equation tool, it is possible to create monitoring, alarming, and control schemes using timers, running minimum/maximum functions, prebuilt analog and discrete logic functions.
When it comes to safety, there are often layers involved before a full shutdown takes place.
There are various phases a process or vessel reaches where mitigating steps can occur to avoid dire or unwanted consequences. Voting logic typically ends up incorporated to look for more than one or two breached variables before countermeasures occur. The SLA can configure built-in logic voting capability that avoids complex ladder logic or other programming complexities.
Cost and time savings can apply to a safety solution. A multiloop logic solver can bring a cost-effective and comprehensive temperature stratification safety solution by simultaneously monitoring temperature across three zones, providing alarming capabilities, and offering shutdown functionality.

