EDITOR’S NOTE: Cyber insurance has been a hot discussion across the industry, at the Level Zero, OT Cybersecurity 2025 Conference, cyber insurance was an important topic of interest. This is a second part of a two-part discussion on the subject.
By Gregory Hale
Within any enterprise, whenever there is a problem, in most cases it can track down to a lack of communication, so when it comes to cybersecurity insurance, the manufacturing team has to be able to work with – and partner with – the insurer for the best and more cost-effective coverage.
That means questions need asking and responses have to be open and honest. In this day of always having to look over your shoulder to protect yourself, this is easier said than done.
“The reason why underwriters need to ask the questions is to be able to price your risk transparently so you know if your price goes up or down or your terms and conditions are changing, that they’re based on your actions and what implications it has on your risk,” said Monica Tigleanu, cyber strategy director at the BMS Group which offers insurance and reinsurance solutions during her talk at the inaugural Level Zero, OT Cybersecurity 2025 Conference in Atlanta, Georgia. “But brokers would insist that sometimes omitting information, it creates an arbitrage in terms of how you price risk. You kind of have options. You can provide more information and have less volatility when it comes to what insurance you’re purchasing and how you’re constructing your contract.
“Or you can trade on, just do an outside scan and see what I look like and give me a price for my risk. That is more of an exposure conversation. Exposure meaning that you’re actually calculating the financial risk that a company has as a result of what you’ve decided to do, how you’ve decided to architect your IT and OT, and how those processes and systems come together. People get very anxious when you start asking them questions about why you made decisions on why you made this IT system be 100 percent dependable on the OT. It’s like checking somebody’s homework. And we need to work more on understanding that is a demonstrable answer. We can demonstrate why we made those decisions because otherwise that’s a good indication of why you need to change those dependencies.”
Open Discussion
This is where open communications comes into play.
“I’ve worked with some insurers on underwriting maybe 10 years ago and was in a lot of underwriting conversations,” said David White, president at Axio, a cyber risk management firm, during the talk. “The insurer that I was working with focused on really big companies that were buying a lot of insurance.
“The underwriting process often involves an interview with the underwriters, a call with typically the CISO or CIO of the organization sitting with maybe a consultant and a few others around the table asking a bunch of questions. I’ve been on calls with Fortune 500 companies looking to get insurance where I was like, we’re walking away from this risk. We’re definitely not taking this risk. Because you have the CIO at a Fortune 500 company saying we’re not encrypting any of our data.
“My bottom line is that transparency is good,” White said. “Insurers have access to data that we all want access to because they see frequency of claims, size of claims and what’s causing losses. And so, if you’re working with a savvy insurer and watch how they change the questions they ask on an annual basis, it tells you a lot. View those questions as open-source intel on the kind of claims they’ve seen in the last year, and you can glean a lot of information that way.
Ask Questions
“You can also ask them outright, like, what are you seeing? Are you paying a lot of claims? We’re worried about this risk. Are you paying a lot of claims to that? What are you seeing as the primary way that that claim is happening? And your insurer as partner should be willing to share that information with you as well,” White said. “Make it into a bilateral partnership and transparent relationship and work with insurer that’s willing to share their data with you.”
A partnership needs communication from the right people.
Insurance companies “unfortunately they are not getting the feedback straight from the professionals, from the engineers, from the OT professionals on what they actually would like to see in terms of support and financing,” Tigleanu said. “There seems to be this blockage between your profession and the insurance world in terms of the communication channels being open. “If you have not been part of an insurance underwriting call, you should definitely try to get yourself involved, meet the people that are part of that conversation so you can understand who your underwriters are, what are they looking for, but also have that open communication channel to say I do need to have support with this network visibility program or I want to perform a cyber-informed engineering assessment. What sort of financial support can the insurance company provide? Would you be able to sponsor that?”
In the end, insurance helps keep organizations resilient to help them stay up and running to continue making product.
Risk Quantification
“That’s why insurance is important,” White said. “But it’s also why risk quantification is important. Because understanding what that really bad day could look like that would bring an organization to its knees is important as part of your internal risk discussion.”
Insurance isn’t the only answer to protect against a cyberattack, but by communicating what you need, and it will be possible to bridge the gap to ensure your organization has the right protection in case of a devastating effect from an attack.

