By Gregory Hale
Cybersecurity insurance for manufacturing can be confusing, confounding or collaborative, depending on your level of understanding, but one thing is for sure, the more you know about your system and your risk, you will better understand your coverage options to protect your organization.
With that in mind as threats to critical infrastructure grow, the role of risk transfer mechanisms like insurance has become more important. But make no mistake about it, there is complexity.
“More than 25 years ago, cyber insurance was created on the basis of privacy liability and in most cases insurance in the financial line sector, meaning you have a financial loss is based on liability principles,” said Monica Tigleanu, cyber strategy director at the BMS Group which offers insurance and reinsurance solutions during her talk at the inaugural Level Zero, OT Cybersecurity 2025 Conference in Atlanta, Georgia. “It was definitely not intended for critical national infrastructure as a buyer.”
“It was meant for e-commerce companies, financial institutions that already had regulations in place that could protect information or confidential information,” she said. “Fast forward to 2025 and the cyber insurance market looks something like $16.6 billion in terms of premiums. There is an estimation out there that 40 percent of U.S. energy companies buy cyber insurance.
Protect Against Interruption
“And 40 percent is not a good penetration rate considering the fact that it’s critical national infrastructure. What exists out there are cyber insurance products that can protect against business interruption losses which are non-physical types of losses. They deal with the actual profits that companies make or their operational viability.
“Additionally, they also cover the extra expenses when you have to get back up and running as an institution, any sort of emergency costs. They also cover physical damage. And you might wonder why they’re covering physical damage in cyber insurance because a lot of people will tell you, especially if they work in the insurance sector, that cyber insurance has a property damage exclusion.
“Then property coverages have cyber exclusions because property underwriters only really knew how to underwrite or analyze risk that was fortuitous or by chance. So, they had to exclude cyber events because those are considered to be malicious or driven by human behavior. And that sits in a different line of business, mostly to do with crime, terrorism And I think some of us remember that post 9-11 the terrorism insurance market was a mess and that is where the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act (TRIA) came into play,” Tigleanu said.
Cyber insurance remained dynamic over the years and continues to evolve.
Insurance Evolves
“There is cyber the insurance, which is an off the shelf form that will cover financial damages from a breach event or ransomware event or something like that,” said David White, President, Axio, a cyber risk management firm, during the talk. “There’s that standard sort of product and then there’s cyber the peril. And for organizations like critical infrastructure or organizations with a very heavy dependence on OT, it’s really worth looking at cyber as a peril and then modeling your own risk.
“A friend of mine said no insurer wants to underwrite you for a risk that you don’t understand. If you’re really interested in getting financial backing as part of your risk management program, the first step is to understand that risk.“That’s where quantification comes into play,” White said. “If you go to the market and show and demonstrate to the insurance market that you have a great understanding of your own risk exposure, then you’re much more likely to get great coverage that meets your risk exposure where it lies, which is unique for you.”
Tigleanu also said insurance was only thought of in one way.“I think we jumped into insurance as kind of the only way that a risk can be transferred,” she said during the roundtable discussion. “Because I think that’s like the default that everybody has. When we think about risk, we either accept it, mitigate it, or we just transfer it. And that’s insurance. But actually, to transfer risk, you have a lot of different options outside of insurance. Insurance is a traditional way of transferring risk. And that market is a regulated market where you have exclusions, and you have deductibles and retention.
Alternative Risk Transfer
“There’s a whole other world out there that critical national infrastructure accesses. That is alternative risk transfer. These are non-traditional ways of transferring risk things like captive pools, which is where TRIA comes into play. You have structured financial solutions. These are things that do not fit in a risk sharing. So, a uniform way of taking risk, sits in the alternative risk transfer market. And that is unfortunately what people think of as oh my God, it’s very complex,” she said. “But it’s actually the best solution sometimes for critical national infrastructure for things like war, for things like emerging risks that you may not have had in an insurance product regulated or adopted by a lot of insurance players.
With an understanding of the risk market, Tigleanu and White pointed toward looking at what cyber risks are out there now that asset owners are most concerned about.“Most risk managers, CFOs and CEOs want to talk about ransomware because that has been the constant subject. There’s a lot of public private conversation about it,” Tigleanu said. “And that means the first thing that comes onto the agenda is ransomware that can cause physical damage or can have a contribution to causing physical damage or disrupt operations or the non-physical implications. I think business email compromise comes up way more than it should. And there is a frequency of payments in terms of what organizations want to get coverage for, which is concerning.”
White said he also remains surprised at the success of business email compromises.
Business Email Compromise
“I thought that was a risk that we largely solved. I heard a story about a client who had lost $25 million to a business email compromise,” he said. “And they felt like they had done everything right. I mean the, the financial guy who actually wired the $25 million to the wrong place got on a Teams call with the CFO and two board members. The problem is he was the only human on that call. The two board members and the CFO were AI generated spoofs based on videos of public appearances of those characters. That was the first time I had heard of AI being used. Ransomware is what I also hear is an issue. In a SANS study, 58 percent of OT disruptions in the most recent survey were based on IT events.
“What happens if we raise the drawbridge, so to speak, and send over the IT network? What happens on the OT side of the house? Yes, ransomware, business email compromise, but OT disruption through IT events I think is a place where we really need as a community to pay a lot more attention.”


Mr. White, cyber insurance is such a huge issue right now …To me, this session really got people thinking …
Greg – thank you for covering our session at Level Zero! Great article.